Thursday, September 23, 2010

What Do We Make of Stephen Hawking’s Claim that God is not Necessary?

In his new book, The Grand Design, Stephen Hawking and his co-author, Leonard Mlodinow, argue that an omnipotent, omniscient God is unnecessary to explain the creation of the universe. Instead, they claim that our universe came into existence spontaneously. There are likely to be many other universes that co-exist with ours, which also came into existence spontaneously and which exist in dimensions that are inaccessible to our senses. Moreover, these universes vary in their physical laws. For example, they say, “In some universes electrons have the weight of golf balls and the force of gravity is stronger than that of magnetism.”

Several propositions form the basis for Hawking’s argument. First, the principles of quantum mechanics demonstrate that matter can behave very differently from behavior we associate with conventional physical laws. For example, sub-atomic particles can come into existence spontaneously, suggesting that this phenomenon on a massive scale could result in the creation of an entire universe.

Second, if universes can come into existence spontaneously, we would expect there to be many universes, not just one. We cannot detect such universes, however, because, as predicted by “superstring” or “M-theory,” these other universes exist in dimensions that cannot be experienced by us. (Another implication is that the conditions for the spontaneous creation of a universe may not come along very often, and there may have been millions of “near misses” that did not lead to a stable universe of any kind.)

Third, no net energy is required to create a universe. As Caltech physicist, Sean Carroll, claims, “It costs precisely zero energy (and zero anything else) to make an entire universe. From that perspective, it’s not surprising that the universe did come into existence.” The implication from these observations is that our universe and many others exist without the need to assume a divine creator or some external source of energy.

The Grand Design has been criticized for being based on tenuous science. See, for example, the review in the New York Times by Dwight Garner, on September 5, 2010. Our limited understanding of the nature of our universe (much less any other universe) means that a book like The Grand Design is inherently speculative. Nevertheless, the evidence is growing that there are plausible theories to explain the creation of our universe that do not require the existence of a divine creator. This evidence was not available to the great scientists in human history, such as Isaac Newton, who could not conceive of a universe that was created without divine intervention, and it is hard for the rest of us to comprehend it today. Ultimately, however, science will probably explain how our universe was created and the primitive assumptions that have guided our thinking throughout history will be obliterated. Science is unlikely to achieve a consensus explanation in our lifetime, but the progress that has been made suggests that there will be such a consensus at some point.

The fundamental question, however, is not the specifics of how our universe was created. The more important questions are these: What is our conception of God and what do discoveries about the origins of the universe tell us about the nature and meaning of our existence? As I argue in The Uncertain Believer, it is essential that we develop a conception of God that is consistent with science. In my view, the most persuasive conception of God is a God that has nothing to do with the Big Bang, the origins of life on earth, or evolution. Instead, we should think of God as the highest and most important – we can use the word sacred – aspect of our existence. In other words, God incorporates the highest ideal of our life. We carry this ideal in our consciousness from generation to generation. We can call this ideal the spirit of love in the universe, if we think of “spirit” as an ideal in our collective social consciousness, rather than an entity that roams through the universe with its own consciousness and agenda for our lives.

In The Uncertain Believer, I suggest that conventional views about the “creation” of the universe are similar to those of a primitive village, which lived thousands of years ago at the foot of a volcano. The people in the village could not conceive of how the volcano periodically erupted and spewed hot lava down the mountainside unless a divine god lived in the volcano. Consequently, they worshiped the volcano and made sacrifices to it. Today, we understand how magma below the earth's surface periodically breaks through the earth’s crust and explodes onto the surface. Consequently, we take the volcano for granted and do not attribute any divine significance to it. Nevertheless, like the primitive inhabitants of this ancient village, we tend to worship what we cannot understand. We assume a divine creator made the universe because we cannot fathom how it could exist otherwise. But that primitive instinct is not a sufficient basis to worship a creator of the universe – or to decide about the nature of God. We are free to rethink our views about God and to move beyond the conception we have inherited from our pre-scientific ancestors.

The author is a Washington attorney and the author of The Uncertain Believer: Reconciling God and Science (SterlingHouse Publisher, Inc., 2009). Correia takes a profound look at the doubt and uncertainty millions face when presented with the traditional conception of God. The Uncertain Believer: Reconciling God and Science (SterlingHouse Publisher, Inc., 2009) addresses the skepticism and indecision that plagues those who no longer find it easy to accept the existence of a supernatural creator. Confronted with the often unappealing alternatives of agnosticism, atheism, and blind faith, The Uncertain Believer offers readers a fresh look at the meaningful role God can play in our lives.

Wednesday, September 8, 2010

The Troubling Theology of Glenn Beck

Fox commentator Glenn Beck’s recent rally on the Mall in Washington was intended to recast him as a spiritual leader. Beck’s religious messages during the rally were fairly general, but in his broadcasts he has been more pointed in criticizing the religious beliefs of President Obama and Christian liberals generally. In particular, he claims that they see the world from the perspective of victims and oppressors rather than individual salvation.

For example, on one of his broadcasts, he said: "You see, it's all about victims and victimhood; oppressors and the oppressed; reparations, not repentance; collectivism, not individual salvation. I don't know what that is, other than it's not Muslim, it's not Christian. It's a perversion of the gospel of Jesus Christ as most Christians know it."

There are three problems with Beck’s theological critique, if it is possible to call it that. The first is that he claims to understand the deep spiritual beliefs of millions of people, including the President, with not much to go on but his disagreement with their politics. The truth is that he doesn’t know what other people believe.

The second is that he is the one ignoring much of Jesus’ message. Political conservatives would like to claim that Jesus stood for individualism and every man for himself in the free market. But if we recall what Jesus actually said, the message is very different. Recall some of his Jesus’ statements about the rich and the poor --
How hard is it for them that trust in riches to enter into the kingdom of God!"(Mark 10:24).
It is easier for a camel to go through the eye of a needle, than for a rich man to enter the kingdom of heaven." (Matthew 19:24)
Sell all that thou hast, and distribute unto the poor, and thou shalt have treasure in heaven." (Luke 18:22)

A modern politician who used that kind of language would probably be branded as a socialist, or at least as someone engaging in class warfare. But Jesus was conveying the Jewish apocalyptic vision of his day. The poor would soon inherit the earth and the rich and powerful would get their comeuppance. Arguing that Jesus’ views were somehow more consistent with reducing financial regulation, cutting taxes, and leaving the poor to the vagaries of the private health market is absurd.

The more fundamental problem, however, is that Beck claims to know the “correct” approach to God and spirituality. The truth is that none of us can be certain about the nature of God and the ultimate meaning of our existence. The best we can do is try to make sense of the universe and live according to the values we identify as highest and best. It is good that Glenn Beck, Sarah Palin, President Obama and millions of others think about spiritual issues and genuinely want to find a place for God in their lives. It also makes sense to consider what Jesus, Mohammed, the Buddha, and anyone else (including Glenn Beck) have to say about them. The problem starts, though, when someone claims to know the right approach and demands that our political leaders and everyone else follow it. It becomes worse when do not accept the sincerity of those who believe differently than we do. Let us respect Glenn Beck’s approach to God and spirituality and ask him to do the same for others.


* The author is a Washington attorney and the author of The Uncertain Believer: Reconciling God and Science (SterlingHouse Publisher, Inc., 2009). Correia takes a profound look at the doubt and uncertainty millions face when presented with the traditional conception of God. The Uncertain Believer: Reconciling God and Science (SterlingHouse Publisher, Inc., 2009) addresses the skepticism and indecision that plagues those who no longer find it easy to accept the existence of a supernatural creator. Confronted with the often unappealing alternatives of agnosticism, atheism, and blind faith, The Uncertain Believer offers readers a fresh look at the meaningful role God can play in our lives.

Monday, August 2, 2010

Rethinking God in New York

The people of New York City have an opportunity to rethink their conception of God. In particular, it is an ideal time to reconsider the notion that the God of Islam is somehow fundamentally different from the God of Jews and Christians.

There is currently a very emotional and potentially destructive dispute over a proposal to build a mosque near the site where the Twin Towers once stood. Many conservative politicians say that allowing the mosque to be built would be a concession to Islam. It would reward the Islamic world with a public relations victory and convey a message of defeat by the United States. Even the American Defamation League, one of the strongest and most consistent voices for tolerance in our country, opposes the mosque.

But what the is the stronger and more enduring message – that Islam scores a public relations “coup” or that we in the United States have respect for all religious faiths, including Islam?

At the secular level, the core of the American tradition is that we believe in liberty enough to sacrifice American lives and treasure to secure it, not only for Americans but for others. Liberty not only includes freedom of religion, that is arguably the first freedom. Look at the Bill of Rights and the First Amendment. It begins with the principle that the United States shall establish no religion and shall allow all persons the right to choose their faith. We are justifiably proud of our Constitution, which has been the model for other constitutions around the world. We would be supremely hypocritical if we held out our Constitution as the model for other countries and then ignored it.

The right approach is even more compelling at a spiritual level. Recall that the three great religious traditions in the western world – Judaism, Islam and Christianity – look to Abraham as their patriarch. Surely Abraham prayed to the same God that Muslims, Christians, and Jews pray to today. Although they may think of God in different ways, the central unifying idea of all three religions is that there is one God and that God represents what is highest and best – and sacred – in our existence. However we see that God, we celebrate that unifying idea when Muslims build a mosque near the site of the destruction of the Twin Towers – and Christians and Jews welcome their doing so.

* The author is a Washington attorney and the author of The Uncertain Believer: Reconciling God and Science (SterlingHouse Publisher, Inc., 2009). Correia takes a profound look at the doubt and uncertainty millions face when presented with the traditional conception of God. The Uncertain Believer: Reconciling God and Science (SterlingHouse Publisher, Inc., 2009) addresses the skepticism and indecision that plagues those who no longer find it easy to accept the existence of a supernatural creator. Confronted with the often unappealing alternatives of agnosticism, atheism, and blind faith, The Uncertain Believer offers readers a fresh look at the meaningful role God can play in our lives.
The views expressed in this blog are not necessarily the views of SterlingHouse Publisher or its affiliates.