In his new book, The Grand Design, Stephen Hawking and his co-author, Leonard Mlodinow, argue that an omnipotent, omniscient God is unnecessary to explain the creation of the universe. Instead, they claim that our universe came into existence spontaneously. There are likely to be many other universes that co-exist with ours, which also came into existence spontaneously and which exist in dimensions that are inaccessible to our senses. Moreover, these universes vary in their physical laws. For example, they say, “In some universes electrons have the weight of golf balls and the force of gravity is stronger than that of magnetism.”
Several propositions form the basis for Hawking’s argument. First, the principles of quantum mechanics demonstrate that matter can behave very differently from behavior we associate with conventional physical laws. For example, sub-atomic particles can come into existence spontaneously, suggesting that this phenomenon on a massive scale could result in the creation of an entire universe.
Second, if universes can come into existence spontaneously, we would expect there to be many universes, not just one. We cannot detect such universes, however, because, as predicted by “superstring” or “M-theory,” these other universes exist in dimensions that cannot be experienced by us. (Another implication is that the conditions for the spontaneous creation of a universe may not come along very often, and there may have been millions of “near misses” that did not lead to a stable universe of any kind.)
Third, no net energy is required to create a universe. As Caltech physicist, Sean Carroll, claims, “It costs precisely zero energy (and zero anything else) to make an entire universe. From that perspective, it’s not surprising that the universe did come into existence.” The implication from these observations is that our universe and many others exist without the need to assume a divine creator or some external source of energy.
The Grand Design has been criticized for being based on tenuous science. See, for example, the review in the New York Times by Dwight Garner, on September 5, 2010. Our limited understanding of the nature of our universe (much less any other universe) means that a book like The Grand Design is inherently speculative. Nevertheless, the evidence is growing that there are plausible theories to explain the creation of our universe that do not require the existence of a divine creator. This evidence was not available to the great scientists in human history, such as Isaac Newton, who could not conceive of a universe that was created without divine intervention, and it is hard for the rest of us to comprehend it today. Ultimately, however, science will probably explain how our universe was created and the primitive assumptions that have guided our thinking throughout history will be obliterated. Science is unlikely to achieve a consensus explanation in our lifetime, but the progress that has been made suggests that there will be such a consensus at some point.
The fundamental question, however, is not the specifics of how our universe was created. The more important questions are these: What is our conception of God and what do discoveries about the origins of the universe tell us about the nature and meaning of our existence? As I argue in The Uncertain Believer, it is essential that we develop a conception of God that is consistent with science. In my view, the most persuasive conception of God is a God that has nothing to do with the Big Bang, the origins of life on earth, or evolution. Instead, we should think of God as the highest and most important – we can use the word sacred – aspect of our existence. In other words, God incorporates the highest ideal of our life. We carry this ideal in our consciousness from generation to generation. We can call this ideal the spirit of love in the universe, if we think of “spirit” as an ideal in our collective social consciousness, rather than an entity that roams through the universe with its own consciousness and agenda for our lives.
In The Uncertain Believer, I suggest that conventional views about the “creation” of the universe are similar to those of a primitive village, which lived thousands of years ago at the foot of a volcano. The people in the village could not conceive of how the volcano periodically erupted and spewed hot lava down the mountainside unless a divine god lived in the volcano. Consequently, they worshiped the volcano and made sacrifices to it. Today, we understand how magma below the earth's surface periodically breaks through the earth’s crust and explodes onto the surface. Consequently, we take the volcano for granted and do not attribute any divine significance to it. Nevertheless, like the primitive inhabitants of this ancient village, we tend to worship what we cannot understand. We assume a divine creator made the universe because we cannot fathom how it could exist otherwise. But that primitive instinct is not a sufficient basis to worship a creator of the universe – or to decide about the nature of God. We are free to rethink our views about God and to move beyond the conception we have inherited from our pre-scientific ancestors.
The author is a Washington attorney and the author of The Uncertain Believer: Reconciling God and Science (SterlingHouse Publisher, Inc., 2009). Correia takes a profound look at the doubt and uncertainty millions face when presented with the traditional conception of God. The Uncertain Believer: Reconciling God and Science (SterlingHouse Publisher, Inc., 2009) addresses the skepticism and indecision that plagues those who no longer find it easy to accept the existence of a supernatural creator. Confronted with the often unappealing alternatives of agnosticism, atheism, and blind faith, The Uncertain Believer offers readers a fresh look at the meaningful role God can play in our lives.
Thursday, September 23, 2010
Wednesday, September 8, 2010
The Troubling Theology of Glenn Beck
Fox commentator Glenn Beck’s recent rally on the Mall in Washington was intended to recast him as a spiritual leader. Beck’s religious messages during the rally were fairly general, but in his broadcasts he has been more pointed in criticizing the religious beliefs of President Obama and Christian liberals generally. In particular, he claims that they see the world from the perspective of victims and oppressors rather than individual salvation.
For example, on one of his broadcasts, he said: "You see, it's all about victims and victimhood; oppressors and the oppressed; reparations, not repentance; collectivism, not individual salvation. I don't know what that is, other than it's not Muslim, it's not Christian. It's a perversion of the gospel of Jesus Christ as most Christians know it."
There are three problems with Beck’s theological critique, if it is possible to call it that. The first is that he claims to understand the deep spiritual beliefs of millions of people, including the President, with not much to go on but his disagreement with their politics. The truth is that he doesn’t know what other people believe.
The second is that he is the one ignoring much of Jesus’ message. Political conservatives would like to claim that Jesus stood for individualism and every man for himself in the free market. But if we recall what Jesus actually said, the message is very different. Recall some of his Jesus’ statements about the rich and the poor --
How hard is it for them that trust in riches to enter into the kingdom of God!"(Mark 10:24).
It is easier for a camel to go through the eye of a needle, than for a rich man to enter the kingdom of heaven." (Matthew 19:24)
Sell all that thou hast, and distribute unto the poor, and thou shalt have treasure in heaven." (Luke 18:22)
A modern politician who used that kind of language would probably be branded as a socialist, or at least as someone engaging in class warfare. But Jesus was conveying the Jewish apocalyptic vision of his day. The poor would soon inherit the earth and the rich and powerful would get their comeuppance. Arguing that Jesus’ views were somehow more consistent with reducing financial regulation, cutting taxes, and leaving the poor to the vagaries of the private health market is absurd.
The more fundamental problem, however, is that Beck claims to know the “correct” approach to God and spirituality. The truth is that none of us can be certain about the nature of God and the ultimate meaning of our existence. The best we can do is try to make sense of the universe and live according to the values we identify as highest and best. It is good that Glenn Beck, Sarah Palin, President Obama and millions of others think about spiritual issues and genuinely want to find a place for God in their lives. It also makes sense to consider what Jesus, Mohammed, the Buddha, and anyone else (including Glenn Beck) have to say about them. The problem starts, though, when someone claims to know the right approach and demands that our political leaders and everyone else follow it. It becomes worse when do not accept the sincerity of those who believe differently than we do. Let us respect Glenn Beck’s approach to God and spirituality and ask him to do the same for others.
* The author is a Washington attorney and the author of The Uncertain Believer: Reconciling God and Science (SterlingHouse Publisher, Inc., 2009). Correia takes a profound look at the doubt and uncertainty millions face when presented with the traditional conception of God. The Uncertain Believer: Reconciling God and Science (SterlingHouse Publisher, Inc., 2009) addresses the skepticism and indecision that plagues those who no longer find it easy to accept the existence of a supernatural creator. Confronted with the often unappealing alternatives of agnosticism, atheism, and blind faith, The Uncertain Believer offers readers a fresh look at the meaningful role God can play in our lives.
For example, on one of his broadcasts, he said: "You see, it's all about victims and victimhood; oppressors and the oppressed; reparations, not repentance; collectivism, not individual salvation. I don't know what that is, other than it's not Muslim, it's not Christian. It's a perversion of the gospel of Jesus Christ as most Christians know it."
There are three problems with Beck’s theological critique, if it is possible to call it that. The first is that he claims to understand the deep spiritual beliefs of millions of people, including the President, with not much to go on but his disagreement with their politics. The truth is that he doesn’t know what other people believe.
The second is that he is the one ignoring much of Jesus’ message. Political conservatives would like to claim that Jesus stood for individualism and every man for himself in the free market. But if we recall what Jesus actually said, the message is very different. Recall some of his Jesus’ statements about the rich and the poor --
How hard is it for them that trust in riches to enter into the kingdom of God!"(Mark 10:24).
It is easier for a camel to go through the eye of a needle, than for a rich man to enter the kingdom of heaven." (Matthew 19:24)
Sell all that thou hast, and distribute unto the poor, and thou shalt have treasure in heaven." (Luke 18:22)
A modern politician who used that kind of language would probably be branded as a socialist, or at least as someone engaging in class warfare. But Jesus was conveying the Jewish apocalyptic vision of his day. The poor would soon inherit the earth and the rich and powerful would get their comeuppance. Arguing that Jesus’ views were somehow more consistent with reducing financial regulation, cutting taxes, and leaving the poor to the vagaries of the private health market is absurd.
The more fundamental problem, however, is that Beck claims to know the “correct” approach to God and spirituality. The truth is that none of us can be certain about the nature of God and the ultimate meaning of our existence. The best we can do is try to make sense of the universe and live according to the values we identify as highest and best. It is good that Glenn Beck, Sarah Palin, President Obama and millions of others think about spiritual issues and genuinely want to find a place for God in their lives. It also makes sense to consider what Jesus, Mohammed, the Buddha, and anyone else (including Glenn Beck) have to say about them. The problem starts, though, when someone claims to know the right approach and demands that our political leaders and everyone else follow it. It becomes worse when do not accept the sincerity of those who believe differently than we do. Let us respect Glenn Beck’s approach to God and spirituality and ask him to do the same for others.
* The author is a Washington attorney and the author of The Uncertain Believer: Reconciling God and Science (SterlingHouse Publisher, Inc., 2009). Correia takes a profound look at the doubt and uncertainty millions face when presented with the traditional conception of God. The Uncertain Believer: Reconciling God and Science (SterlingHouse Publisher, Inc., 2009) addresses the skepticism and indecision that plagues those who no longer find it easy to accept the existence of a supernatural creator. Confronted with the often unappealing alternatives of agnosticism, atheism, and blind faith, The Uncertain Believer offers readers a fresh look at the meaningful role God can play in our lives.
Monday, August 2, 2010
Rethinking God in New York
The people of New York City have an opportunity to rethink their conception of God. In particular, it is an ideal time to reconsider the notion that the God of Islam is somehow fundamentally different from the God of Jews and Christians.
There is currently a very emotional and potentially destructive dispute over a proposal to build a mosque near the site where the Twin Towers once stood. Many conservative politicians say that allowing the mosque to be built would be a concession to Islam. It would reward the Islamic world with a public relations victory and convey a message of defeat by the United States. Even the American Defamation League, one of the strongest and most consistent voices for tolerance in our country, opposes the mosque.
But what the is the stronger and more enduring message – that Islam scores a public relations “coup” or that we in the United States have respect for all religious faiths, including Islam?
At the secular level, the core of the American tradition is that we believe in liberty enough to sacrifice American lives and treasure to secure it, not only for Americans but for others. Liberty not only includes freedom of religion, that is arguably the first freedom. Look at the Bill of Rights and the First Amendment. It begins with the principle that the United States shall establish no religion and shall allow all persons the right to choose their faith. We are justifiably proud of our Constitution, which has been the model for other constitutions around the world. We would be supremely hypocritical if we held out our Constitution as the model for other countries and then ignored it.
The right approach is even more compelling at a spiritual level. Recall that the three great religious traditions in the western world – Judaism, Islam and Christianity – look to Abraham as their patriarch. Surely Abraham prayed to the same God that Muslims, Christians, and Jews pray to today. Although they may think of God in different ways, the central unifying idea of all three religions is that there is one God and that God represents what is highest and best – and sacred – in our existence. However we see that God, we celebrate that unifying idea when Muslims build a mosque near the site of the destruction of the Twin Towers – and Christians and Jews welcome their doing so.
* The author is a Washington attorney and the author of The Uncertain Believer: Reconciling God and Science (SterlingHouse Publisher, Inc., 2009). Correia takes a profound look at the doubt and uncertainty millions face when presented with the traditional conception of God. The Uncertain Believer: Reconciling God and Science (SterlingHouse Publisher, Inc., 2009) addresses the skepticism and indecision that plagues those who no longer find it easy to accept the existence of a supernatural creator. Confronted with the often unappealing alternatives of agnosticism, atheism, and blind faith, The Uncertain Believer offers readers a fresh look at the meaningful role God can play in our lives.
There is currently a very emotional and potentially destructive dispute over a proposal to build a mosque near the site where the Twin Towers once stood. Many conservative politicians say that allowing the mosque to be built would be a concession to Islam. It would reward the Islamic world with a public relations victory and convey a message of defeat by the United States. Even the American Defamation League, one of the strongest and most consistent voices for tolerance in our country, opposes the mosque.
But what the is the stronger and more enduring message – that Islam scores a public relations “coup” or that we in the United States have respect for all religious faiths, including Islam?
At the secular level, the core of the American tradition is that we believe in liberty enough to sacrifice American lives and treasure to secure it, not only for Americans but for others. Liberty not only includes freedom of religion, that is arguably the first freedom. Look at the Bill of Rights and the First Amendment. It begins with the principle that the United States shall establish no religion and shall allow all persons the right to choose their faith. We are justifiably proud of our Constitution, which has been the model for other constitutions around the world. We would be supremely hypocritical if we held out our Constitution as the model for other countries and then ignored it.
The right approach is even more compelling at a spiritual level. Recall that the three great religious traditions in the western world – Judaism, Islam and Christianity – look to Abraham as their patriarch. Surely Abraham prayed to the same God that Muslims, Christians, and Jews pray to today. Although they may think of God in different ways, the central unifying idea of all three religions is that there is one God and that God represents what is highest and best – and sacred – in our existence. However we see that God, we celebrate that unifying idea when Muslims build a mosque near the site of the destruction of the Twin Towers – and Christians and Jews welcome their doing so.
* The author is a Washington attorney and the author of The Uncertain Believer: Reconciling God and Science (SterlingHouse Publisher, Inc., 2009). Correia takes a profound look at the doubt and uncertainty millions face when presented with the traditional conception of God. The Uncertain Believer: Reconciling God and Science (SterlingHouse Publisher, Inc., 2009) addresses the skepticism and indecision that plagues those who no longer find it easy to accept the existence of a supernatural creator. Confronted with the often unappealing alternatives of agnosticism, atheism, and blind faith, The Uncertain Believer offers readers a fresh look at the meaningful role God can play in our lives.
Sunday, June 6, 2010
The Jewish People and Moral Leadership
The Jewish people can legitimately claim to have been in the vanguard of the moral growth of humanity. The western tradition of monotheism began with the insistence of the Jews that there is one God. The central tenets of Christianity and Islam are built on that belief. Millions of children have been taught the principles of the Ten Commandments, which the Bible tells us were brought down from the mountain by Moses. The central passage in the Bible, in which Jesus says that the two most important laws are to love God and love our neighbor, is not integral to the Jewish faith, but we should remember these words were spoken by a Jew to Jewish listeners in order to convince them that these are the most important values of religion. Over the centuries, Jews have made obedience to God’s laws the center of not only their religious faith but the conduct of their lives. Historically, they asked only to be left alone to practice their traditions and observe their faith.
Sometime during the twentieth century, however, this role of moral leadership became secondary to the goal of preserving and protecting Israel. The recent incident in which Israeli soldiers boarded a Turkish ship bring supplies to Gaza, and the reaction to it, is the latest illustration. It is true that some of the passengers on the ship had motives other than humanitarian ones. The soldiers were attacked with iron bars and reacted by firing their weapons. This violent confrontation should have been avoided altogether, however, by using some other approach to preventing potentially dangerous cargo from reaching Gaza. The truth is that Israel used a violent, rather than non-violent strategy, which not only resulted in the deaths of nine passengers but hurt the interests of Israel itself. It is difficult to reconcile this incident with the notion that obedience to God’s laws is at the center of Jewish life.
The tension between protecting the security of Israel and preserving the great moral tradition of the Jewish people is felt most acutely in Israel itself, of course. But it is reflected in the divisions among Jews in the United States as well. Part of the Jewish community, generally older and more orthodox, has steadfastly defended the actions of Israel under Prime Minister Netanyahu, not only in the boarding of the Turkish ship, but in expanding settlements in the West Bank, and generally taking a harder line toward the Palestinians. Increasingly, younger and more liberal Jews in the U.S. find themselves at odds with these policies.
Preserving the original values of Judaism and the security of Israel are distinct goals and they are always in conflict to some extent. However, the rest of the world can hope that the Jewish people, both in the United States and Israel, will find a way to achieve both and in doing so regain their role of moral leadership.
*Correia takes a profound look at the doubt and uncertainty millions face when presented with the traditional conception of God. The Uncertain Believer: Reconciling God and Science (SterlingHouse Publisher, Inc., 2009) addresses the skepticism and indecision that plagues those who no longer find it easy to accept the existence of a supernatural creator. Confronted with the often unappealing alternatives of agnosticism, atheism, and blind faith, The Uncertain Believer offers readers a fresh look at the meaningful role God can play in our lives.
Sometime during the twentieth century, however, this role of moral leadership became secondary to the goal of preserving and protecting Israel. The recent incident in which Israeli soldiers boarded a Turkish ship bring supplies to Gaza, and the reaction to it, is the latest illustration. It is true that some of the passengers on the ship had motives other than humanitarian ones. The soldiers were attacked with iron bars and reacted by firing their weapons. This violent confrontation should have been avoided altogether, however, by using some other approach to preventing potentially dangerous cargo from reaching Gaza. The truth is that Israel used a violent, rather than non-violent strategy, which not only resulted in the deaths of nine passengers but hurt the interests of Israel itself. It is difficult to reconcile this incident with the notion that obedience to God’s laws is at the center of Jewish life.
The tension between protecting the security of Israel and preserving the great moral tradition of the Jewish people is felt most acutely in Israel itself, of course. But it is reflected in the divisions among Jews in the United States as well. Part of the Jewish community, generally older and more orthodox, has steadfastly defended the actions of Israel under Prime Minister Netanyahu, not only in the boarding of the Turkish ship, but in expanding settlements in the West Bank, and generally taking a harder line toward the Palestinians. Increasingly, younger and more liberal Jews in the U.S. find themselves at odds with these policies.
Preserving the original values of Judaism and the security of Israel are distinct goals and they are always in conflict to some extent. However, the rest of the world can hope that the Jewish people, both in the United States and Israel, will find a way to achieve both and in doing so regain their role of moral leadership.
*Correia takes a profound look at the doubt and uncertainty millions face when presented with the traditional conception of God. The Uncertain Believer: Reconciling God and Science (SterlingHouse Publisher, Inc., 2009) addresses the skepticism and indecision that plagues those who no longer find it easy to accept the existence of a supernatural creator. Confronted with the often unappealing alternatives of agnosticism, atheism, and blind faith, The Uncertain Believer offers readers a fresh look at the meaningful role God can play in our lives.
Friday, May 21, 2010
Three Scenarios for the Future of God
Assume for a moment that the most sensible conception of God is that God is not external to the world, but, instead, God is carried in our consciousness as the highest, most important – we can say “sacred” -- aspects of our existence. What could we say about the future of God? One implication would be that God is not eternal since human consciousness is not eternal. Some day our species will be extinct, although some future, more intelligent species may keep the concept of God alive. But, on the assumption that homo sapiens has at least a few millennia left, what is going to happen to God? Consider three scenarios.
One scenario is that God drifts out of our consciousness. That is periodically the prediction of social scientists, based on survey data that show the percentage of people who say they believe in God has steadily declined in economically developed countries. In this first scenario, this trend would continue and extend to other parts of the world. In a century or two, let’s say, the idea of God would become increasingly irrelevant, until it would become nothing more than an interesting subject of historical study. Friedrich Nietzsche’s proclamation that “God is dead” would be justified, just a few centuries late. In my view, this would be a tragic loss for humanity because we would lose the central unifying idea that gives us a historical link with our ancestors and a way to bridge the divide among people who do not share the same religious creeds and doctrines.
A second scenario is that the conceptions of God held by different cultures diverge even more dramatically than they do today. In the west, for example, the conception of God might become more spiritual and less anthropomorphic. God would be open to all, and there would be no favored or disfavored groups. In other cultures, the conception God might continue to be much like in the Old Testament. God would be on the side of some groups and condemn others. Those who profess to follow God’s wishes might even claim that God commands them to engage in violence in order to follow the “true path to righteousness.” As a result of these radically different visions of God, religious differences become even more stark and cultures with radically different conceptions of God find it increasingly difficult to understand each other.
A third scenario is a hopeful one. Mankind comes to develop a shared conception of God. In this conception, God does not take sides or favor one group over another. There is no anthropomorphic God who commands us to adopt one creed and reject others. Instead, we see God as the central unifying idea that the most important -- the most sacred -- aspect of our existence is to have compassion for each other. That shared conception would not solve all of our problems or answer all our questions, but it would give us a common framework for finding answers. We cannot be certain that this vision can ever become a reality, but there is value in the vision and in working toward it.
Correia takes a profound look at the doubt and uncertainty millions face when presented with the traditional conception of God. The Uncertain Believer: Reconciling God and Science (SterlingHouse Publisher, Inc., 2009) addresses the skepticism and indecision that plagues those who no longer find it easy to accept the existence of a supernatural creator. Confronted with the often unappealing alternatives of agnosticism, atheism, and blind faith, The Uncertain Believer offers readers a fresh look at the meaningful role God can play in our lives.
One scenario is that God drifts out of our consciousness. That is periodically the prediction of social scientists, based on survey data that show the percentage of people who say they believe in God has steadily declined in economically developed countries. In this first scenario, this trend would continue and extend to other parts of the world. In a century or two, let’s say, the idea of God would become increasingly irrelevant, until it would become nothing more than an interesting subject of historical study. Friedrich Nietzsche’s proclamation that “God is dead” would be justified, just a few centuries late. In my view, this would be a tragic loss for humanity because we would lose the central unifying idea that gives us a historical link with our ancestors and a way to bridge the divide among people who do not share the same religious creeds and doctrines.
A second scenario is that the conceptions of God held by different cultures diverge even more dramatically than they do today. In the west, for example, the conception of God might become more spiritual and less anthropomorphic. God would be open to all, and there would be no favored or disfavored groups. In other cultures, the conception God might continue to be much like in the Old Testament. God would be on the side of some groups and condemn others. Those who profess to follow God’s wishes might even claim that God commands them to engage in violence in order to follow the “true path to righteousness.” As a result of these radically different visions of God, religious differences become even more stark and cultures with radically different conceptions of God find it increasingly difficult to understand each other.
A third scenario is a hopeful one. Mankind comes to develop a shared conception of God. In this conception, God does not take sides or favor one group over another. There is no anthropomorphic God who commands us to adopt one creed and reject others. Instead, we see God as the central unifying idea that the most important -- the most sacred -- aspect of our existence is to have compassion for each other. That shared conception would not solve all of our problems or answer all our questions, but it would give us a common framework for finding answers. We cannot be certain that this vision can ever become a reality, but there is value in the vision and in working toward it.
Correia takes a profound look at the doubt and uncertainty millions face when presented with the traditional conception of God. The Uncertain Believer: Reconciling God and Science (SterlingHouse Publisher, Inc., 2009) addresses the skepticism and indecision that plagues those who no longer find it easy to accept the existence of a supernatural creator. Confronted with the often unappealing alternatives of agnosticism, atheism, and blind faith, The Uncertain Believer offers readers a fresh look at the meaningful role God can play in our lives.
Thursday, April 1, 2010
What is the Future of God?
What is the future of God? Many people would say that question makes no sense on the grounds that God is eternal and constant. They would argue that God has always existed and will exist long after the human species is extinct. But that view assumes that God is like the God of the Bible -- external to the world, existing independent of man and all other living things. In this conception, God “lived” in a vast empty universe (at least empty of humans) for fourteen billion years or so after the Big Bang, until eventually humans evolved on earth. Of course, God may have occupied his attention with intelligent species that evolved earlier on other planets so divine life in the universe was not completely boring but under any reasonable assumptions about evolution of intelligent life, there were billions of years between the Big Bang and intelligent life. The point is that the existence of God has nothing to do with the existence of anyone or anything else.
If this image of God as an anthropomorphic being sitting in any empty universe does not make sense, we could choose to say, as Paul Tillich did, that God is the “ground of being.” That conception might seem to fit with a universe devoid of humans. Or, we could agree with Spinoza and say that God is all of nature, even if nature doesn’t happen to include humans. But under these conceptions, what would God be – a “spirit” occupying the vast empty spaces of the universe, or even the atoms that make up lifeless primordial galaxies? That God is certainly impressive, but what does it mean for our lives? What does it tell us about how we should live or relate to our families?
Doesn’t it make more sense to say that God is not external to the world, existing independent of humans? Instead, the existence of God is dependent on the existence of man because God is carried from generation in our consciousness as the highest and most sacred aspect of our existence. Doesn’t it make more sense to say that man created God, rather than that God created man, but that reversal of the creation story does not undermine the significance and sacredness of the idea of God? If we go down this path, then we see that the future of God becomes a very important question.
Hegel believed that the Absolute Idea – his notion of God – exists in the consciousness of the community. One does not have to accept Hegel’s view of history to agree that the highest values of humans are carried from generation to generation in human consciousness. If God is the central unifying idea of what is sacred in human existence – and if that idea is carried through history in human consciousness – then we have a window into the future of God. God will disappear when human consciousness ends. The more troubling possibility is that God may disappear long before humans disappear because humans stop taking God seriously.
Toward the end of the nineteenth century, Friedrich Nietzsche claimed that “God is dead.” Although he probably believed in something like the God of the Bible, I believe his point is roughly equivalent to the popular expression, “You’re dead to me.” In other words, if we stop taking the idea of God seriously, if God is no more than lip service, then God becomes dead to us. We do not have to accept Nietzsche’s conception of God to conclude that much of the world is at that point. In order to start taking God seriously, we have to rethink our conception of God. An essential step in that process is to find a way to reconcile God with science. If we do not, then at some point, not this century or the next, perhaps, but eventually, God will fade away.
Correia takes a profound look at the doubt and uncertainty millions face when presented with the traditional conception of God. The Uncertain Believer: Reconciling God and Science (SterlingHouse Publisher, Inc., 2009) addresses the skepticism and indecision that plagues those who no longer find it easy to accept the existence of a supernatural creator. Confronted with the often unappealing alternatives of agnosticism, atheism, and blind faith, The Uncertain Believer offers readers a fresh look at the meaningful role God can play in our lives.
If this image of God as an anthropomorphic being sitting in any empty universe does not make sense, we could choose to say, as Paul Tillich did, that God is the “ground of being.” That conception might seem to fit with a universe devoid of humans. Or, we could agree with Spinoza and say that God is all of nature, even if nature doesn’t happen to include humans. But under these conceptions, what would God be – a “spirit” occupying the vast empty spaces of the universe, or even the atoms that make up lifeless primordial galaxies? That God is certainly impressive, but what does it mean for our lives? What does it tell us about how we should live or relate to our families?
Doesn’t it make more sense to say that God is not external to the world, existing independent of humans? Instead, the existence of God is dependent on the existence of man because God is carried from generation in our consciousness as the highest and most sacred aspect of our existence. Doesn’t it make more sense to say that man created God, rather than that God created man, but that reversal of the creation story does not undermine the significance and sacredness of the idea of God? If we go down this path, then we see that the future of God becomes a very important question.
Hegel believed that the Absolute Idea – his notion of God – exists in the consciousness of the community. One does not have to accept Hegel’s view of history to agree that the highest values of humans are carried from generation to generation in human consciousness. If God is the central unifying idea of what is sacred in human existence – and if that idea is carried through history in human consciousness – then we have a window into the future of God. God will disappear when human consciousness ends. The more troubling possibility is that God may disappear long before humans disappear because humans stop taking God seriously.
Toward the end of the nineteenth century, Friedrich Nietzsche claimed that “God is dead.” Although he probably believed in something like the God of the Bible, I believe his point is roughly equivalent to the popular expression, “You’re dead to me.” In other words, if we stop taking the idea of God seriously, if God is no more than lip service, then God becomes dead to us. We do not have to accept Nietzsche’s conception of God to conclude that much of the world is at that point. In order to start taking God seriously, we have to rethink our conception of God. An essential step in that process is to find a way to reconcile God with science. If we do not, then at some point, not this century or the next, perhaps, but eventually, God will fade away.
Correia takes a profound look at the doubt and uncertainty millions face when presented with the traditional conception of God. The Uncertain Believer: Reconciling God and Science (SterlingHouse Publisher, Inc., 2009) addresses the skepticism and indecision that plagues those who no longer find it easy to accept the existence of a supernatural creator. Confronted with the often unappealing alternatives of agnosticism, atheism, and blind faith, The Uncertain Believer offers readers a fresh look at the meaningful role God can play in our lives.
Saturday, March 20, 2010
What is the Future of God?
I was recently privileged to join Professor Tom Boyd of the University of Oklahoma and Professor Robin Meyers of Oklahoma City University in a panel discussion of “The Future of God.” (You can hear an audio recording of the panel at http://casweb.ou.edu/home/news/events/daa2010_lectures.html.) Some members of the audience were clearly puzzled by the topic. A frequent reaction was this: God is eternal and never-changing, so there is no point in speculating about His future. That reaction makes sense only if we have a conception of God that is like the one described in the Bible.
Let’s suppose for a moment that God really is eternal and never-changing. We immediately confront the puzzle that the God of the New Testament is very different from the God of the Old Testament. The God of the Old Testament is stern and temperamental. He loses his temper and imposes massive suffering on non-believers. But when we learn about God in the New Testament, Jesus paints a picture of a loving and forgiving father. There is no punishment of non-believers, no anger, no slaughter of enemies. What’s going on? Did God change in the centuries between the exodus of the Jews from Egypt to the time when Jesus lived or did mankind’s conception of God change?
Even within the Old Testament, the image of God changes radically. Recall that God is described in Genesis as walking through the Garden of Eden in the cool of the day. He seems surprised that Adam and Eve would eat fruit from the Tree of Knowledge of Good and Evil and He is angry that Cain would kill his brother. In other words, He appears as a very powerful, but very human-like entity. By the time we get to Moses, however, God appears as a pillar of fire and a burning bush. He speaks and thinks in a very human-like way, but he is a more mysterious and distant figure. The writers of those passages were trying to imagine the most powerful, the most “perfect” being they could.
Consider the proposition that God is not external to the world. Instead, assume that God exists in our consciousness as what each generation conceives to be the highest and most important – the most sacred -- aspect of our existence. I have argued in The Uncertain Believer that it makes sense for mankind in the 21st century to think of this aspect of our life as the ideal of unqualified compassion for others. At the individual level, that means God is the intellectual and emotional ideal of love for our neighbor. At the social level, that means God is the spirit of love in the world.
Once we think of God as existing in our consciousness in this way, we can understand that each generation in history tries to conceptualize God in a way that captures what they believe to be the most important, the most perfect aspects of existence. To the ancient Jews, that meant that the essential characteristic of God was power – power over nature, power to destroy enemies, power to create the world. As science explains the working of nature, however, we are free to rethink the essential characteristics of God. It makes more sense to say that God is highest and most sacred ideal of existence -- the ideal that inspires to be as perfect as we can be. In other words, God is changing as we change. In my next comment, I will suggest what that means for the future of God.
* Correia takes a profound look at the doubt and uncertainty millions face when presented with the traditional conception of God. The Uncertain Believer: Reconciling God and Science (SterlingHouse Publisher, Inc., 2009) addresses the skepticism and indecision that plagues those who no longer find it easy to accept the existence of a supernatural creator. Confronted with the often unappealing alternatives of agnosticism, atheism, and blind faith, The Uncertain Believer offers readers a fresh look at the meaningful role God can play in our lives.
Let’s suppose for a moment that God really is eternal and never-changing. We immediately confront the puzzle that the God of the New Testament is very different from the God of the Old Testament. The God of the Old Testament is stern and temperamental. He loses his temper and imposes massive suffering on non-believers. But when we learn about God in the New Testament, Jesus paints a picture of a loving and forgiving father. There is no punishment of non-believers, no anger, no slaughter of enemies. What’s going on? Did God change in the centuries between the exodus of the Jews from Egypt to the time when Jesus lived or did mankind’s conception of God change?
Even within the Old Testament, the image of God changes radically. Recall that God is described in Genesis as walking through the Garden of Eden in the cool of the day. He seems surprised that Adam and Eve would eat fruit from the Tree of Knowledge of Good and Evil and He is angry that Cain would kill his brother. In other words, He appears as a very powerful, but very human-like entity. By the time we get to Moses, however, God appears as a pillar of fire and a burning bush. He speaks and thinks in a very human-like way, but he is a more mysterious and distant figure. The writers of those passages were trying to imagine the most powerful, the most “perfect” being they could.
Consider the proposition that God is not external to the world. Instead, assume that God exists in our consciousness as what each generation conceives to be the highest and most important – the most sacred -- aspect of our existence. I have argued in The Uncertain Believer that it makes sense for mankind in the 21st century to think of this aspect of our life as the ideal of unqualified compassion for others. At the individual level, that means God is the intellectual and emotional ideal of love for our neighbor. At the social level, that means God is the spirit of love in the world.
Once we think of God as existing in our consciousness in this way, we can understand that each generation in history tries to conceptualize God in a way that captures what they believe to be the most important, the most perfect aspects of existence. To the ancient Jews, that meant that the essential characteristic of God was power – power over nature, power to destroy enemies, power to create the world. As science explains the working of nature, however, we are free to rethink the essential characteristics of God. It makes more sense to say that God is highest and most sacred ideal of existence -- the ideal that inspires to be as perfect as we can be. In other words, God is changing as we change. In my next comment, I will suggest what that means for the future of God.
* Correia takes a profound look at the doubt and uncertainty millions face when presented with the traditional conception of God. The Uncertain Believer: Reconciling God and Science (SterlingHouse Publisher, Inc., 2009) addresses the skepticism and indecision that plagues those who no longer find it easy to accept the existence of a supernatural creator. Confronted with the often unappealing alternatives of agnosticism, atheism, and blind faith, The Uncertain Believer offers readers a fresh look at the meaningful role God can play in our lives.
Monday, February 15, 2010
What Verse Do You Want on Your Bumper Sticker?
I just finished a wonderful book by Robin R. Meyers called Saving Jesus from the Church (HarperOne 2009). Meyers argues that Christians should concentrate on the message of Jesus, rather than the question of whether Jesus was the divine Son of God. Or, as Meyers puts it in the subtitle of the book, "How to Stop Worshipping Christ and Start Following Jesus.” If we go down this path, we don’t need to struggle over whether Jesus was a man or a man and God combined, or whether he was equal or subordinate to God – the questions that occupied the Catholic Church for centuries. These controversies continue to create religious fault lines around the world and often do little or nothing to help us live more loving and meaningful lives.
Whatever one thinks of the nature of Jesus, his words (or at least the words attributed to him) reflect the greatest insights of all the words of wisdom in the Bible. Recall the trick question posed to Jesus by the rabbis, hoping to discredit him. What is the greatest commandment, they asked? Jesus replied: “And thou shall love the Lord thy God with all thy heart, and with all thy soul, and with all thy mind, and with all thy strength; this is the first commandment. And the second is like, namely this, Thou shall love thy neighbor as thyself. There is none other commandment greater than these.” Mark 12: 30-31. That is a remarkably progressive message, which has nothing to do with rigid religious laws or rituals. In my view, if we are to take one central unifying idea from the New Testament, it is the ideas found in that passage.
Too often, though, the Church has strayed from this basic message to find itself bogged down in disputes over abstract doctrines and elaborate theological constructs that are not to be found in the words of Jesus or, in fact, in the Bible at all. In a way the question boils down to this: If you are a Christian and have to pick one of these verses from the New Testament for your bumper sticker, what would it be: “For God so loved the world, that he gave his only begotten Son, that whoever believeth in him should not perish, but have everlasting life” (John 3:16) or the passage from Mark above?
The familiar passage in John, which all Christians learn as children, focuses on God loving us and the requirement that we accept Jesus as the Divine Son of God. It is a beautiful thought, but it is all about us -- and the requirement to accept a certain creed. Compare that to the passage in Mark, which focuses on our loving God and our neighbors. Your choice should tell you something about what Christianity means to you.
*Correia takes a profound look at the doubt and uncertainty millions face when presented with the traditional conception of God. The Uncertain Believer: Reconciling God and Science (SterlingHouse Publisher, Inc., 2009) addresses the skepticism and indecision that plagues those who no longer find it easy to accept the existence of a supernatural creator. Confronted with the often unappealing alternatives of agnosticism, atheism, and blind faith, The Uncertain Believer offers readers a fresh look at the meaningful role God can play in our lives.
Whatever one thinks of the nature of Jesus, his words (or at least the words attributed to him) reflect the greatest insights of all the words of wisdom in the Bible. Recall the trick question posed to Jesus by the rabbis, hoping to discredit him. What is the greatest commandment, they asked? Jesus replied: “And thou shall love the Lord thy God with all thy heart, and with all thy soul, and with all thy mind, and with all thy strength; this is the first commandment. And the second is like, namely this, Thou shall love thy neighbor as thyself. There is none other commandment greater than these.” Mark 12: 30-31. That is a remarkably progressive message, which has nothing to do with rigid religious laws or rituals. In my view, if we are to take one central unifying idea from the New Testament, it is the ideas found in that passage.
Too often, though, the Church has strayed from this basic message to find itself bogged down in disputes over abstract doctrines and elaborate theological constructs that are not to be found in the words of Jesus or, in fact, in the Bible at all. In a way the question boils down to this: If you are a Christian and have to pick one of these verses from the New Testament for your bumper sticker, what would it be: “For God so loved the world, that he gave his only begotten Son, that whoever believeth in him should not perish, but have everlasting life” (John 3:16) or the passage from Mark above?
The familiar passage in John, which all Christians learn as children, focuses on God loving us and the requirement that we accept Jesus as the Divine Son of God. It is a beautiful thought, but it is all about us -- and the requirement to accept a certain creed. Compare that to the passage in Mark, which focuses on our loving God and our neighbors. Your choice should tell you something about what Christianity means to you.
*Correia takes a profound look at the doubt and uncertainty millions face when presented with the traditional conception of God. The Uncertain Believer: Reconciling God and Science (SterlingHouse Publisher, Inc., 2009) addresses the skepticism and indecision that plagues those who no longer find it easy to accept the existence of a supernatural creator. Confronted with the often unappealing alternatives of agnosticism, atheism, and blind faith, The Uncertain Believer offers readers a fresh look at the meaningful role God can play in our lives.
Wednesday, January 20, 2010
What Does God Have to do with the Earthquake in Haiti?
The earthquake in Haiti is one of the great human disasters of this young century. Imagine how many thousands of times Haitians have asked themselves: Where is God? Why did He allow this to happen? That is a natural reaction, based on centuries of looking to God to explain natural disasters. But as I discuss in The Uncertain Believer, man has steadily looked to science to understand the phenomena of nature, from the beautiful to the terrible. But this intellectual advance is not universal and, even among those who tend to reject “divine” explanations , it still may be difficult to think God has nothing to do with such overwhelming destruction and loss of life.
Consider three possible roles for God in the Haiti disaster. The first is the one we associate with our primitive ancestors who understood natural disasters as punishment by God. Evangelist Pat Robertson is a good example of someone who takes this position. On his television shows, the “700 Club,” he claimed that the disaster was God’s revenge for a “pact with the Devil” that Haitians had made to gain their independence from France over 200 years ago.
One of the few virtues of this explanation is that it is dramatic, much more interesting than a scientific analysis of the tectonic plates beneath the Caribbean. Another is that it assumes a rational cause and effect calculus by God that is part of the complex rules that govern the universe: If you make a pact with the Devil, I will punish you. This at least means that God is not handing out suffering arbitrarily and on a whim, as the Greek Gods sometimes did.
On the other hand, how can Pat Robertson or anyone else love (or at least respect) a God that is too weak to prevent a pact with the Devil in the first place and is so cruel as to inflict this level of suffering two hundred years after the transgression. Wouldn’t a loving God have simply used His power to prevent the pact in the first place? And, while he was at it, give Haitians the education, health care and economic development to prevent the squalid poverty in which they have lived for centuries? If we go down this road with Pat Robertson, we arrive at a conception of God that is so far removed from a loving God that we may have a sense of despair.
Another approach is to say that God is nature itself, both the terrible and the beautiful. This is the conception the Vatican sees in the movie Avatar and was concerned enough to issue a statement condemning this vision. It is certainly possible to conceive of God as nature. One can be particularly attracted to this vision when we experience spectacularly beautiful or amazingly complex phenomena. They literally take our breath away. Some philosophers (Spinoza for one) held that God is nature and primitive pantheism finds God in rocks, trees and rivers. If we go down this road, we see the Haitian earthquake as one of the infinite aspects of God, but there is no rational cause and effect calculation, no idea of punishment. God is simply God – beautiful and ugly, destructive and constructive, life-giving and life-taking. Step back and behold.
But if we go down this road, we begin to see all the problems with this conception, too. If God is everything we see around us, what guidance does that give us about our lives ? Is there a framework for living in the mountains, rivers and earthquakes? How does this idea of God help us in our relationships? How does it lead to a better world? We are at a dead end because, once God becomes everything, the idea of God fades into the background of everyday reality, and, paradoxically, God can become nothing.
The third conception of God is the one that makes sense to me and this God is glaringly evident in Haiti. This is God as the ideal of unqualified compassion for others. I argue in The Uncertain Believer that this is the central unifying idea of all major religions.* If we conceive of God in this way, we see God at work in the heroic efforts of rescue workers and in those who comfort the dying and those who have lost loved ones. We even see God in the response of nations throughout the world to send recue ships and pour in supplies, and to commit resources to rebuild a devastated society. Yes, there is self-interest at work in much of this, as there always is, but there is genuine compassion, too. This idea of God does provide a framework for living. It provides hope for the future of the world.
*Correia takes a profound look at the doubt and uncertainty millions face when presented with the traditional conception of God. The Uncertain Believer: Reconciling God and Science (SterlingHouse Publisher, Inc., 2009) addresses the skepticism and indecision that plagues those who no longer find it easy to accept the existence of a supernatural creator. Confronted with the often unappealing alternatives of agnosticism, atheism, and blind faith, The Uncertain Believer offers readers a fresh look at the meaningful role God can play in our lives. (see www.uncertainbeliever.com)
Consider three possible roles for God in the Haiti disaster. The first is the one we associate with our primitive ancestors who understood natural disasters as punishment by God. Evangelist Pat Robertson is a good example of someone who takes this position. On his television shows, the “700 Club,” he claimed that the disaster was God’s revenge for a “pact with the Devil” that Haitians had made to gain their independence from France over 200 years ago.
One of the few virtues of this explanation is that it is dramatic, much more interesting than a scientific analysis of the tectonic plates beneath the Caribbean. Another is that it assumes a rational cause and effect calculus by God that is part of the complex rules that govern the universe: If you make a pact with the Devil, I will punish you. This at least means that God is not handing out suffering arbitrarily and on a whim, as the Greek Gods sometimes did.
On the other hand, how can Pat Robertson or anyone else love (or at least respect) a God that is too weak to prevent a pact with the Devil in the first place and is so cruel as to inflict this level of suffering two hundred years after the transgression. Wouldn’t a loving God have simply used His power to prevent the pact in the first place? And, while he was at it, give Haitians the education, health care and economic development to prevent the squalid poverty in which they have lived for centuries? If we go down this road with Pat Robertson, we arrive at a conception of God that is so far removed from a loving God that we may have a sense of despair.
Another approach is to say that God is nature itself, both the terrible and the beautiful. This is the conception the Vatican sees in the movie Avatar and was concerned enough to issue a statement condemning this vision. It is certainly possible to conceive of God as nature. One can be particularly attracted to this vision when we experience spectacularly beautiful or amazingly complex phenomena. They literally take our breath away. Some philosophers (Spinoza for one) held that God is nature and primitive pantheism finds God in rocks, trees and rivers. If we go down this road, we see the Haitian earthquake as one of the infinite aspects of God, but there is no rational cause and effect calculation, no idea of punishment. God is simply God – beautiful and ugly, destructive and constructive, life-giving and life-taking. Step back and behold.
But if we go down this road, we begin to see all the problems with this conception, too. If God is everything we see around us, what guidance does that give us about our lives ? Is there a framework for living in the mountains, rivers and earthquakes? How does this idea of God help us in our relationships? How does it lead to a better world? We are at a dead end because, once God becomes everything, the idea of God fades into the background of everyday reality, and, paradoxically, God can become nothing.
The third conception of God is the one that makes sense to me and this God is glaringly evident in Haiti. This is God as the ideal of unqualified compassion for others. I argue in The Uncertain Believer that this is the central unifying idea of all major religions.* If we conceive of God in this way, we see God at work in the heroic efforts of rescue workers and in those who comfort the dying and those who have lost loved ones. We even see God in the response of nations throughout the world to send recue ships and pour in supplies, and to commit resources to rebuild a devastated society. Yes, there is self-interest at work in much of this, as there always is, but there is genuine compassion, too. This idea of God does provide a framework for living. It provides hope for the future of the world.
*Correia takes a profound look at the doubt and uncertainty millions face when presented with the traditional conception of God. The Uncertain Believer: Reconciling God and Science (SterlingHouse Publisher, Inc., 2009) addresses the skepticism and indecision that plagues those who no longer find it easy to accept the existence of a supernatural creator. Confronted with the often unappealing alternatives of agnosticism, atheism, and blind faith, The Uncertain Believer offers readers a fresh look at the meaningful role God can play in our lives. (see www.uncertainbeliever.com)
Tuesday, January 5, 2010
Does the Islamic Faith Condone Violence?
On the last day of 2009, the Washington Post ran a story on its front page about Nidal Hasan, the Army psychiatrist who killed a dozen people at Fort Hood in November. The article explored the influence of Islam on Hasan’s views about military service and his apparent conclusion that he was justified in killing Americans in the military. The front page prominently displayed two quotes from the Quran. “And whoever kills a believer intentionally, his punishment is hell; he shall abide in it, and Allah will send His wrath on him and curse him and prepare him for a painful chastisement.” (Chapter 4, verse 93) The second quote was: “[D]o not kill anyone whose killing Allah has forbidden, except for just cause.” (Chapter 17, verse 33).
It is possible that Hasan interpreted the first verse to mean that the United States, by sending troops to Iraq and Afghanistan, deserved punishment from Allah. It is also possible that Hasan interpreted the second verse to mean that he, not just Allah, was justified in killing “unbelievers” at his base. One can go even further and say that this is not just Hasan’s interpretation of the Quran. It is the INTENDED interpretation. In other words, one could argue that the Quran, and by extension, the Islamic faith, holds that killing “unbelievers” is justified, at least if they are involved in a military occupation that results in the loss of Muslim lives. That principle could apply to Israel’s control of the West Bank, to U.S. actions in the Middle East, to any nation or person who is viewed as being “at war” with Muslims.
There is no doubt that many in the radical Islamic movement believe violence, even against innocent civilians, is justified by the Quran. There is also no doubt that the traditional interpretation of the Quran, the one held by the vast majority of Muslims around the world, rejects this view. As in the case of all religious movements that have been historically intertwined with political and social conflicts, armies have marched in the name of Islam. But that is also true of the ancient Jews, who conquered tribes in Palestine, and Christians, who launched the Crusades in the eleventh century to “retake” the Holy Land. The issue is not whether violence has been practiced in the name of a religious movement but what are the core values that it represents today. Islam, like all other great religious traditions teaches us to love others as we loves ourselves. (See Mohammed’s version of the Golden Rule as well as that of other religions at www.religioustolerance.org/reciproc.htm.)
The problem is not the core teachings of Islam. The problem is a widespread and growing radical Islamic movement that is a perversion of traditional Islam. The causes for that movement are many, but at least one is that moderate Islamic leaders around the world are not vocal enough about how the traditional teachings of Islam are being distorted. It is essential to separate the political conflicts over the Middle East from the central teachings of the great religious traditions. We can have fundamental disagreements over the former, but we are to a great extent united about the latter. That is a message we need to hear from all religious leaders, but more than ever, we need to hear it from Islam.
It is possible that Hasan interpreted the first verse to mean that the United States, by sending troops to Iraq and Afghanistan, deserved punishment from Allah. It is also possible that Hasan interpreted the second verse to mean that he, not just Allah, was justified in killing “unbelievers” at his base. One can go even further and say that this is not just Hasan’s interpretation of the Quran. It is the INTENDED interpretation. In other words, one could argue that the Quran, and by extension, the Islamic faith, holds that killing “unbelievers” is justified, at least if they are involved in a military occupation that results in the loss of Muslim lives. That principle could apply to Israel’s control of the West Bank, to U.S. actions in the Middle East, to any nation or person who is viewed as being “at war” with Muslims.
There is no doubt that many in the radical Islamic movement believe violence, even against innocent civilians, is justified by the Quran. There is also no doubt that the traditional interpretation of the Quran, the one held by the vast majority of Muslims around the world, rejects this view. As in the case of all religious movements that have been historically intertwined with political and social conflicts, armies have marched in the name of Islam. But that is also true of the ancient Jews, who conquered tribes in Palestine, and Christians, who launched the Crusades in the eleventh century to “retake” the Holy Land. The issue is not whether violence has been practiced in the name of a religious movement but what are the core values that it represents today. Islam, like all other great religious traditions teaches us to love others as we loves ourselves. (See Mohammed’s version of the Golden Rule as well as that of other religions at www.religioustolerance.org/reciproc.htm.)
The problem is not the core teachings of Islam. The problem is a widespread and growing radical Islamic movement that is a perversion of traditional Islam. The causes for that movement are many, but at least one is that moderate Islamic leaders around the world are not vocal enough about how the traditional teachings of Islam are being distorted. It is essential to separate the political conflicts over the Middle East from the central teachings of the great religious traditions. We can have fundamental disagreements over the former, but we are to a great extent united about the latter. That is a message we need to hear from all religious leaders, but more than ever, we need to hear it from Islam.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)
