Sunday, June 6, 2010

The Jewish People and Moral Leadership

The Jewish people can legitimately claim to have been in the vanguard of the moral growth of humanity. The western tradition of monotheism began with the insistence of the Jews that there is one God. The central tenets of Christianity and Islam are built on that belief. Millions of children have been taught the principles of the Ten Commandments, which the Bible tells us were brought down from the mountain by Moses. The central passage in the Bible, in which Jesus says that the two most important laws are to love God and love our neighbor, is not integral to the Jewish faith, but we should remember these words were spoken by a Jew to Jewish listeners in order to convince them that these are the most important values of religion. Over the centuries, Jews have made obedience to God’s laws the center of not only their religious faith but the conduct of their lives. Historically, they asked only to be left alone to practice their traditions and observe their faith.

Sometime during the twentieth century, however, this role of moral leadership became secondary to the goal of preserving and protecting Israel. The recent incident in which Israeli soldiers boarded a Turkish ship bring supplies to Gaza, and the reaction to it, is the latest illustration. It is true that some of the passengers on the ship had motives other than humanitarian ones. The soldiers were attacked with iron bars and reacted by firing their weapons. This violent confrontation should have been avoided altogether, however, by using some other approach to preventing potentially dangerous cargo from reaching Gaza. The truth is that Israel used a violent, rather than non-violent strategy, which not only resulted in the deaths of nine passengers but hurt the interests of Israel itself. It is difficult to reconcile this incident with the notion that obedience to God’s laws is at the center of Jewish life.

The tension between protecting the security of Israel and preserving the great moral tradition of the Jewish people is felt most acutely in Israel itself, of course. But it is reflected in the divisions among Jews in the United States as well. Part of the Jewish community, generally older and more orthodox, has steadfastly defended the actions of Israel under Prime Minister Netanyahu, not only in the boarding of the Turkish ship, but in expanding settlements in the West Bank, and generally taking a harder line toward the Palestinians. Increasingly, younger and more liberal Jews in the U.S. find themselves at odds with these policies.

Preserving the original values of Judaism and the security of Israel are distinct goals and they are always in conflict to some extent. However, the rest of the world can hope that the Jewish people, both in the United States and Israel, will find a way to achieve both and in doing so regain their role of moral leadership.


*Correia takes a profound look at the doubt and uncertainty millions face when presented with the traditional conception of God. The Uncertain Believer: Reconciling God and Science (SterlingHouse Publisher, Inc., 2009) addresses the skepticism and indecision that plagues those who no longer find it easy to accept the existence of a supernatural creator. Confronted with the often unappealing alternatives of agnosticism, atheism, and blind faith, The Uncertain Believer offers readers a fresh look at the meaningful role God can play in our lives.
The views expressed in this blog are not necessarily the views of SterlingHouse Publisher or its affiliates.