It has been some time since I posted a blog comment. I admit to having been a little discouraged about whether it is possible for societies to make progress in breaking down religious differences. However, I have a renewed commitment to this goal after reading President Obama’s Nobel Peace Prize acceptance speech.
I highly recommend that you read this speech in its entirety. Even if you think he didn’t deserve the prize and even if you disagree with his decision to send more troops to Afghanistan, I believe you will find the speech to be a powerful attempt to justify war without rejecting a philosophy of non-violence. To oversimplify a bit, his argument is that war is justified now because there is evil in the world, but someday mankind may advance to a point when war is unnecessary. As he put it, “the non-violence practiced by men like Ghandi and King may not have been practical or possible in every circumstance, but the love they preached – their faith in human progress – must always be the North Star that guides us on our journey.”
What does God have to do with the goal of eliminating war, since nations have routinely claimed that God is on their side when they engage in wars, both just and unjust? In my view, the role of God is to serve as a central unifying idea that the highest value in life is love of others. That in turn provides an ideal that mankind as a whole – as well as individuals in their own lives – can strive to achieve. This idea is not unique to Christianity or to any religion. As the President said, religion has been used to justify the murder of innocents, but “such a warped view of religion is not just incompatible with the concept of peace, but the purpose of faith – for the one rule that lies at the heart of every major religion is that we do unto others as we would have them do unto us.”
In The Uncertain Believer, I argue that the most persuasive conception of God is that God is the ideal of unqualified compassion for others. To love God means to commit oneself to this ideal and participate in this spirit of love in the world. Over the next few months, I want to explore whether – and, if so, how -- this principle is central to all religious traditions. I plan to make that the central theme of my blog comments, not just to repeat the same idea over and over, but to examine whether it is really true that this principle is central to all major religions. If it is, that is powerful proof that, if mankind is ever to accept a common conception of God, it will do so on the basis that love of others should be the central unifying idea of religion. The capacity to embrace this principle is what makes humans special. In other words, we are unique among all species because we have the capacity to love others, not just because our instincts compel us to do so, not just because it is in our self-interest, but because we find meaning and value in doing so.
Tuesday, December 29, 2009
Monday, October 19, 2009
A Downside of Life after Death
The idea that we continue to exist in some form after death is an ancient one, perhaps predating our own species. Neanderthal man practiced burial rites suggesting a belief that the dead would need food and tools. At some point, the afterlife became a place for rewarding those who had lived a worthy life and punishing those who did not. The early Greeks reserved eternal bliss for a few. Most souls existed in a bleak underworld ruled by Hades. Recall Achilles telling Odysseus, who visited him in the underworld, that he would rather be a peasant on earth than a king in the underworld. Dante did as much as anyone to form our conventional image of life after death. In Dante’s Divine Comedy, there are three principal realms of existence, Hell, Purgatory, and Paradise.
Even this three part division of the afterlife is simpler than the one conceived by the Catholic Church. To these three dimensions, unofficial Catholic doctrine added a mysterious place called limbo where innocent souls who had not satisfied certain ritualistic requirements resided forever. Limbo was conceived as a place where the dead did not have the joy of being close to God but were not punished either. There was great dissatisfaction with the idea that the innocent could be stuck in limbo for eternity. Limbo for Infants who died shortly after childbirth but before christening seemed to many to be an obvious injustice. According to Catholic doctrine, at least those in purgatory are able to work their way to heaven. After careful study of the evidence – it’s not clear what evidence was reviewed – the Catholic Church decided that infants go to heaven after all, though limbo still exists for others.
Is the idea of the afterlife good for us? The hope of eternal life can provide meaning to those whose life on earth is filled with suffering. Even a wretched, painful life can become bearable if one believes there a life of eternal happiness follows. Perhaps the most tangible benefit comes at the time we are most likely to focus on our fate after death: when a loved one dies. The deaths of parents, spouses and children are for many the most painful moments in life. We are crushed with grief at the loss. The idea that we will never see our loved ones again can literally be too much to bear. What more comforting vision can there be than the promise that we will join them in heaven after our own death? Those who find comfort in these beliefs are indeed fortunate and I have no desire to convince them otherwise.
But there is a dark side to belief in the afterlife. At a very general level, it helps sustain the intellectual strain in humans that rejects relying on science to explain the universe in favor of imagination and superstition. In general, modern societies have given up explaining natural phenomena on the basis of supernatural forces beyond our ability to study and explain. We rely on empirical observation and science to explain hurricanes, solar eclipses, black holes, and all the other amazing phenomena we observe. But a very large percentage of Americans continue to say they believe in ghosts and other forms of existence after death for which there is no scientific evidence. While these beliefs are not necessarily related to religion, they become easier to accept if heaven is part of conventional wisdom. The proportion of people in less developed countries that have such beliefs is probably even higher. Perhaps there is no great harm from these pre-scientific views of the world if they do not fundamentally affect our behavior.
There is at least one case, however, where belief in the afterlife has a terribly destructive effect. I am thinking of Islamic radicals who blow themselves up in the hope of receiving an eternal reward that goes beyond the ordinary bliss of heaven. For centuries, we have protected ourselves from human predators by threatening to punish them if they harm us. But, if predators do not fear punishment, this strategy becomes futile. A belief in life after death does not turn someone into a suicide bomber, of course. Perhaps illogically, the vast majority of people who believe in heaven still want to live as long as possible. We enjoy life on earth and “heaven can wait.” And in case someone is tempted to take a short-cut to heaven through suicide, the Catholic Church developed the notion that suicide is itself a mortal sin that condemns one to eternal punishment . But, if a young man or woman is taught by religious authorities that suicide is morally right and that killing others in the process increases exponentially the rewards of eternity, a pre-scientific approach to understanding the universe can have its most twisted and destructive effect.
Even this three part division of the afterlife is simpler than the one conceived by the Catholic Church. To these three dimensions, unofficial Catholic doctrine added a mysterious place called limbo where innocent souls who had not satisfied certain ritualistic requirements resided forever. Limbo was conceived as a place where the dead did not have the joy of being close to God but were not punished either. There was great dissatisfaction with the idea that the innocent could be stuck in limbo for eternity. Limbo for Infants who died shortly after childbirth but before christening seemed to many to be an obvious injustice. According to Catholic doctrine, at least those in purgatory are able to work their way to heaven. After careful study of the evidence – it’s not clear what evidence was reviewed – the Catholic Church decided that infants go to heaven after all, though limbo still exists for others.
Is the idea of the afterlife good for us? The hope of eternal life can provide meaning to those whose life on earth is filled with suffering. Even a wretched, painful life can become bearable if one believes there a life of eternal happiness follows. Perhaps the most tangible benefit comes at the time we are most likely to focus on our fate after death: when a loved one dies. The deaths of parents, spouses and children are for many the most painful moments in life. We are crushed with grief at the loss. The idea that we will never see our loved ones again can literally be too much to bear. What more comforting vision can there be than the promise that we will join them in heaven after our own death? Those who find comfort in these beliefs are indeed fortunate and I have no desire to convince them otherwise.
But there is a dark side to belief in the afterlife. At a very general level, it helps sustain the intellectual strain in humans that rejects relying on science to explain the universe in favor of imagination and superstition. In general, modern societies have given up explaining natural phenomena on the basis of supernatural forces beyond our ability to study and explain. We rely on empirical observation and science to explain hurricanes, solar eclipses, black holes, and all the other amazing phenomena we observe. But a very large percentage of Americans continue to say they believe in ghosts and other forms of existence after death for which there is no scientific evidence. While these beliefs are not necessarily related to religion, they become easier to accept if heaven is part of conventional wisdom. The proportion of people in less developed countries that have such beliefs is probably even higher. Perhaps there is no great harm from these pre-scientific views of the world if they do not fundamentally affect our behavior.
There is at least one case, however, where belief in the afterlife has a terribly destructive effect. I am thinking of Islamic radicals who blow themselves up in the hope of receiving an eternal reward that goes beyond the ordinary bliss of heaven. For centuries, we have protected ourselves from human predators by threatening to punish them if they harm us. But, if predators do not fear punishment, this strategy becomes futile. A belief in life after death does not turn someone into a suicide bomber, of course. Perhaps illogically, the vast majority of people who believe in heaven still want to live as long as possible. We enjoy life on earth and “heaven can wait.” And in case someone is tempted to take a short-cut to heaven through suicide, the Catholic Church developed the notion that suicide is itself a mortal sin that condemns one to eternal punishment . But, if a young man or woman is taught by religious authorities that suicide is morally right and that killing others in the process increases exponentially the rewards of eternity, a pre-scientific approach to understanding the universe can have its most twisted and destructive effect.
Tuesday, September 22, 2009
God and Health Care Reform
There are plenty of things wrong with the American health care system: It is inefficient. Ineffective high cost services can waste resources while more effective low cost services are often underused. The private market distorts risk-spreading. Private insurance companies, like any private businesses, try to maximize profits. They do so by trying to sell more policies while minimizing risk. As a result, they often exclude high cost treatments, avoid enrolling people with pre-existing conditions, and impose arbitrary barriers to coverage. However, the worst flaw of the system is that it denies health care to people who do not have access to government-run plans, such as Medicare and Medicaid, or are too poor to obtain private coverage.
It is not surprising that most parties in the debate over health care reform care about their own interests. Doctors and hospitals want to protect their fees. Insurance companies want to protect their premiums. Companies that provide health care products and services do not want to suffer a loss of revenue. And the great majority of Americans, those with more or less adequate health care coverage, want to keep it without paying more. The ultimate result of all these constituencies looking after themselves may doom efforts to change the system, even though polls at the beginning of the debate showed a large majority in favor of reform.
What does God have to do with all of this? Go back to the basic flaw in the system: the uninsured who do not have access to care or who receive care on an ad hoc basis in emergency rooms. You can be sure that this group does not have lobbyists in Washington walking the halls of Congress looking after them. They watch the debate from outside Washington, often wondering what it is about. Ironically, they are often the ones who protest the reform bills most loudly because they have been led to think there are “death panels,” President Obama is going to take away the little coverage they have, or they will have no choice about doctors.
The only way to break the logjam over health care reform is for all us – at least to some extent – to put aside self interest in favor of loving our neighbor. Is that an unrealistic, even laughable, idea? Perhaps. But every major religion has endorsed the core of Jesus’ famous answer to the rabbis when asked to name the most important of God’s laws. He answered with two laws not one: Love God and love your neighbor as yourself. In this case, our neighbors include those people without decent health insurance coverage. That is why the churches have a greater role to play in the health care reform debate. That is why all those who profess to believe in God, in fact, to love God, need to stop thinking only about themselves as Congress considers what to do about our deeply flawed health care system.
It is not surprising that most parties in the debate over health care reform care about their own interests. Doctors and hospitals want to protect their fees. Insurance companies want to protect their premiums. Companies that provide health care products and services do not want to suffer a loss of revenue. And the great majority of Americans, those with more or less adequate health care coverage, want to keep it without paying more. The ultimate result of all these constituencies looking after themselves may doom efforts to change the system, even though polls at the beginning of the debate showed a large majority in favor of reform.
What does God have to do with all of this? Go back to the basic flaw in the system: the uninsured who do not have access to care or who receive care on an ad hoc basis in emergency rooms. You can be sure that this group does not have lobbyists in Washington walking the halls of Congress looking after them. They watch the debate from outside Washington, often wondering what it is about. Ironically, they are often the ones who protest the reform bills most loudly because they have been led to think there are “death panels,” President Obama is going to take away the little coverage they have, or they will have no choice about doctors.
The only way to break the logjam over health care reform is for all us – at least to some extent – to put aside self interest in favor of loving our neighbor. Is that an unrealistic, even laughable, idea? Perhaps. But every major religion has endorsed the core of Jesus’ famous answer to the rabbis when asked to name the most important of God’s laws. He answered with two laws not one: Love God and love your neighbor as yourself. In this case, our neighbors include those people without decent health insurance coverage. That is why the churches have a greater role to play in the health care reform debate. That is why all those who profess to believe in God, in fact, to love God, need to stop thinking only about themselves as Congress considers what to do about our deeply flawed health care system.
Wednesday, August 26, 2009
Does “God” Have to be a Being?
If we stop thinking of God as a being, do we have to stop using the term “God”? Some people who call themselves atheists take this position. See for example, a thoughtful comment by James Tracy. Is he right?
It is possible to use words the way we want, of course, since we make up the definitions. However, I agree with Tracy that it distorts language and leads to confusion if we start defining “dog” to mean cat. However, defining God in some other way than an anthropomorphic being is a more complicated proposition. Even though the majority of persons have used the term that way for thousands of years, there are still good reasons for using the term God more broadly.
First, many important philosophers and theologians have described conceptions of God that are very different from the traditional one. Aristotle’s God was something like pure thought contemplating itself. Spinoza’s God was nature. Hegel’s God was the Absolute, which was something like an ultimate idea to which he believed history moves. Paul Tillich sometimes described God as the “ground of being” and the “ultimate concern.” Some mystical traditions have refused to describe God in concrete terms on the grounds that such a description invariably imposes limits on what is limitless. Instead, they find it possible only to say what God is not. None of these individuals would characterize themselves as atheists. We would be closing ourselves off from these valuable perspectives if we decided not to consider their conceptions of God.
Second, and even more importantly, using the term “God” more broadly than the conception of God described in the Old Testament preserves a tradition – perhaps the most important tradition we have – and creates a link among all those who participate in this tradition. This link is both an historic one and an ideological one. It provides a way for us to share in the beliefs and values of those who have gone before us, as far back as our pre-scientific ancestors who wrote the Old Testament and even earlier. It also provides a way for humans who do not think of God as a being to share in the tradition of those who do.
A Christian conservative, an Islamic mystic in the Suffi tradition, a scientist who (like Einstein) adopts Spinoza’s conception of God, and those (like me) who think of God as the spirit of love in the world all share one fundamental idea. We believe that there is something that is ultimately and supremely important in the universe. We believe there is a sacred dimension to life. By refusing to discard the term “God,” we have a way of sharing in that idea and communicating about it. In the long run, I believe we should contribute to the preservation of this tradition rather than let it fade away as science crushes old assumptions about what humans once attributed to the traditional conception of God.
It is possible to use words the way we want, of course, since we make up the definitions. However, I agree with Tracy that it distorts language and leads to confusion if we start defining “dog” to mean cat. However, defining God in some other way than an anthropomorphic being is a more complicated proposition. Even though the majority of persons have used the term that way for thousands of years, there are still good reasons for using the term God more broadly.
First, many important philosophers and theologians have described conceptions of God that are very different from the traditional one. Aristotle’s God was something like pure thought contemplating itself. Spinoza’s God was nature. Hegel’s God was the Absolute, which was something like an ultimate idea to which he believed history moves. Paul Tillich sometimes described God as the “ground of being” and the “ultimate concern.” Some mystical traditions have refused to describe God in concrete terms on the grounds that such a description invariably imposes limits on what is limitless. Instead, they find it possible only to say what God is not. None of these individuals would characterize themselves as atheists. We would be closing ourselves off from these valuable perspectives if we decided not to consider their conceptions of God.
Second, and even more importantly, using the term “God” more broadly than the conception of God described in the Old Testament preserves a tradition – perhaps the most important tradition we have – and creates a link among all those who participate in this tradition. This link is both an historic one and an ideological one. It provides a way for us to share in the beliefs and values of those who have gone before us, as far back as our pre-scientific ancestors who wrote the Old Testament and even earlier. It also provides a way for humans who do not think of God as a being to share in the tradition of those who do.
A Christian conservative, an Islamic mystic in the Suffi tradition, a scientist who (like Einstein) adopts Spinoza’s conception of God, and those (like me) who think of God as the spirit of love in the world all share one fundamental idea. We believe that there is something that is ultimately and supremely important in the universe. We believe there is a sacred dimension to life. By refusing to discard the term “God,” we have a way of sharing in that idea and communicating about it. In the long run, I believe we should contribute to the preservation of this tradition rather than let it fade away as science crushes old assumptions about what humans once attributed to the traditional conception of God.
Tuesday, August 18, 2009
Should Judges Have Empathy, Compassion or Neither One?
During the hearings on the confirmation of Justice Sonia Sotomayor to the Supreme Court, there was an interesting debate over the role of “empathy” and “compassion” in decision-making by judges. In praising Sotomayor, President Obama commented that empathy and compassion are some of her strengths. In contrast, some conservative opponents argued that a judge who empathizes with others or has compassion for them her will ignore the law in favor of advancing her own agenda. For example, a recent column in American Thinker says: “What America needs right now is courage and mutual respect -- not empathy and sensitivity.”
Should judges have “empathy” or “compassion” and what is the difference between these two ideas anyway? Webster’s New World Dictionary defines “empathy” as the “projection of one’s own personality into the personality of another in order to understand him better.” If you appear before a judge someday and have to explain your particular circumstances, would you want a judge who could mentally step into your shoes for a few minutes? I certainly would. The judge might still rule against you, send you to prison, deny you child custody, or take whatever action the law demanded. But one of the most frustrating, even infuriating, situations one can face is that those who have power over you do not understand your situation.
It is true that Supreme Court Justices don’t decide prison sentences or make rulings in child custody cases. They usually make purely “legal” rulings rather than decide facts. However, these legal rulings including far-reaching interpretations of the Constitution that must take into account real-world personal problems: Should a non-English speaker have a right to an interpreter in legal proceedings? Should the law require that the government provide an elevator to take a disabled person to an upper floor hearing? Should the law allow execution of a mentally disabled person? These and a thousand other cases require Supreme Court Justices to understand, as much as humanly possible, the effects of the law on individuals whose lives are very different from theirs. And, this requirement does not stop with the person who is a party before the court, for example, the defendant in a criminal case. It extends to the victims of a crime and their families, all those who might be affected significantly by a decision. It seems obvious that we want judges who understand the effects of their decisions on real people. Thus, President Obama was right that empathy is an important quality for judges, even Supreme Court Justices.
Although the word “compassion” can connote sympathy or pity, it can also mean a feeling of caring for others, even for those we do not know. In fact, it is the best word we have for genuine love of all other human beings. Should a Supreme Court Justice, or any judge, have compassion? Again, some conservatives say no. For example, Christopher Lasch in his book The Revolt of the Elites, says: “A misplaced compassion degrades both the victims, who are reduced to objects of pity, and their would-be benefactors, who find it easier to pity their fellow citizens than to hold them up to impersonal standards, attainment of which would entitle them to respect."
In The Uncertain Believer, I argue that compassion is the highest value in life. There are certainly many other worthy values, but none is as important or as central as this one. In fact, we can think of God as the central unifying idea that love of others is the highest value in life. The centrality of this value means that we should have compassion for others in whatever we do. That does not mean judges should twist the law because they “feel sorry” for someone who the law says should lose a case just as parents must discipline children whom they deeply love. Our professional, legal or moral obligation may be to send someone to prison, even to launch missiles on a terrorist camp. But in all cases, we should recognize that the people who are affected are human beings, not objects. The point is that the starting point for our basic approach to life should be compassion for others. That gives us a framework for living, from which we can carry out our responsibilities and live up to this highest value in life, or at least come as close as we can.
Should judges have “empathy” or “compassion” and what is the difference between these two ideas anyway? Webster’s New World Dictionary defines “empathy” as the “projection of one’s own personality into the personality of another in order to understand him better.” If you appear before a judge someday and have to explain your particular circumstances, would you want a judge who could mentally step into your shoes for a few minutes? I certainly would. The judge might still rule against you, send you to prison, deny you child custody, or take whatever action the law demanded. But one of the most frustrating, even infuriating, situations one can face is that those who have power over you do not understand your situation.
It is true that Supreme Court Justices don’t decide prison sentences or make rulings in child custody cases. They usually make purely “legal” rulings rather than decide facts. However, these legal rulings including far-reaching interpretations of the Constitution that must take into account real-world personal problems: Should a non-English speaker have a right to an interpreter in legal proceedings? Should the law require that the government provide an elevator to take a disabled person to an upper floor hearing? Should the law allow execution of a mentally disabled person? These and a thousand other cases require Supreme Court Justices to understand, as much as humanly possible, the effects of the law on individuals whose lives are very different from theirs. And, this requirement does not stop with the person who is a party before the court, for example, the defendant in a criminal case. It extends to the victims of a crime and their families, all those who might be affected significantly by a decision. It seems obvious that we want judges who understand the effects of their decisions on real people. Thus, President Obama was right that empathy is an important quality for judges, even Supreme Court Justices.
Although the word “compassion” can connote sympathy or pity, it can also mean a feeling of caring for others, even for those we do not know. In fact, it is the best word we have for genuine love of all other human beings. Should a Supreme Court Justice, or any judge, have compassion? Again, some conservatives say no. For example, Christopher Lasch in his book The Revolt of the Elites, says: “A misplaced compassion degrades both the victims, who are reduced to objects of pity, and their would-be benefactors, who find it easier to pity their fellow citizens than to hold them up to impersonal standards, attainment of which would entitle them to respect."
In The Uncertain Believer, I argue that compassion is the highest value in life. There are certainly many other worthy values, but none is as important or as central as this one. In fact, we can think of God as the central unifying idea that love of others is the highest value in life. The centrality of this value means that we should have compassion for others in whatever we do. That does not mean judges should twist the law because they “feel sorry” for someone who the law says should lose a case just as parents must discipline children whom they deeply love. Our professional, legal or moral obligation may be to send someone to prison, even to launch missiles on a terrorist camp. But in all cases, we should recognize that the people who are affected are human beings, not objects. The point is that the starting point for our basic approach to life should be compassion for others. That gives us a framework for living, from which we can carry out our responsibilities and live up to this highest value in life, or at least come as close as we can.
Thursday, August 6, 2009
What if God Has Nothing to do with the Creation of the Universe?
Most of us were taught as children that God created the world in seven days. As we grew older, however, we learned about the age of the earth, evolution and the Big Bang, the primordial explosion of matter throughout the universe. The Big Bang probably occurred about 13.7 billion years ago, and the earth itself was formed about nine billion years later. Humans in the form of home sapiens developed perhaps 100,000 years ago. Consequently, if we think of “creation” as the history of the universe from the very beginning until the origin of the human species, it took billions of years, not seven days! How is it possible to reconcile these two radically different stories of how the universe was formed?
One way to reconcile the scientific account and the Biblical account is to interpret Genesis as a metaphorical account of creation. God still created the universe but He did so over an extremely long period. We could even look for passages in Genesis that seem consistent with this metaphorical explanation. For example, perhaps we could interpret Genesis 1:3 (“Let there be light and there was light”) as the Big Bang. We could interpret Genesis 1:27 (“God created man in his own image”) as God putting evolution in motion, knowing that the human species would come into existence billions of years later.
The problem with this approach is that it really doesn’t make any sense, does it? The authors of Genesis knew nothing about the how the universe was created. They were restating ancient legends in powerful, poetic language. Besides, would an omnipotent God really start with a fourteen billion year warm-up before getting to the main act? God as Creator is an idea developed by our pre-scientific ancestors who had no way of conceiving how the universe could be formed without a divine hand. Isaac Newton, probably the greatest scientist in history, knew nothing of the Big Bang, subatomic particles, black holes or quantum physics.
All that has changed. Scientists are steadily unraveling the mechanism and cause of the Big Bang by studying deep space and learning more about subatomic particles. For example, scientists at the Fermilab, one of the most powerful particle accelerators in the world, are trying to confirm the existence of a new subatomic particle, called the Higgs boson (or colloquially, the “God particle”) which may explain how all other particles are held together. Paradoxically perhaps, learning more about the behavior of subatomic particles may be the most promising path to understanding the vastness of the universe.
In The Uncertain Believer, I suggest a very different approach to reconciling the idea of God and creation: A modern conception of God has nothing to do with creation. Consequently, we can stop worrying about the role of God in the Big Bang or evolution and concentrate on a conception of God that provides a framework for living. That conception of God can have much greater meaning than the traditional God of the Bible by inspiring us to be as good as we can be. That leads to another paradox: Conceiving of a God that does not have the power to create the universe can lead to a God that has a much more powerful influence in our lives.
One way to reconcile the scientific account and the Biblical account is to interpret Genesis as a metaphorical account of creation. God still created the universe but He did so over an extremely long period. We could even look for passages in Genesis that seem consistent with this metaphorical explanation. For example, perhaps we could interpret Genesis 1:3 (“Let there be light and there was light”) as the Big Bang. We could interpret Genesis 1:27 (“God created man in his own image”) as God putting evolution in motion, knowing that the human species would come into existence billions of years later.
The problem with this approach is that it really doesn’t make any sense, does it? The authors of Genesis knew nothing about the how the universe was created. They were restating ancient legends in powerful, poetic language. Besides, would an omnipotent God really start with a fourteen billion year warm-up before getting to the main act? God as Creator is an idea developed by our pre-scientific ancestors who had no way of conceiving how the universe could be formed without a divine hand. Isaac Newton, probably the greatest scientist in history, knew nothing of the Big Bang, subatomic particles, black holes or quantum physics.
All that has changed. Scientists are steadily unraveling the mechanism and cause of the Big Bang by studying deep space and learning more about subatomic particles. For example, scientists at the Fermilab, one of the most powerful particle accelerators in the world, are trying to confirm the existence of a new subatomic particle, called the Higgs boson (or colloquially, the “God particle”) which may explain how all other particles are held together. Paradoxically perhaps, learning more about the behavior of subatomic particles may be the most promising path to understanding the vastness of the universe.
In The Uncertain Believer, I suggest a very different approach to reconciling the idea of God and creation: A modern conception of God has nothing to do with creation. Consequently, we can stop worrying about the role of God in the Big Bang or evolution and concentrate on a conception of God that provides a framework for living. That conception of God can have much greater meaning than the traditional God of the Bible by inspiring us to be as good as we can be. That leads to another paradox: Conceiving of a God that does not have the power to create the universe can lead to a God that has a much more powerful influence in our lives.
Monday, July 20, 2009
Two Conceptions of God and a Summer Storm
Last weekend my wife and I were in our weekend home in a rural area of eastern Virginia. A tornado, or perhaps a “micro-burst,” swept through the area and downed thousands of trees in a matter of minutes. The storm came suddenly, bringing hurricane-like winds and torrential rain with almost no warning. It lasted no more than ten minutes. Within a half hour, the sun was back out and it was possible to examine the devastation. We learned that the damage was very localized, limited to a few square miles. The drive to our house was littered with huge trees that had been snapped by the wind. By hiking up the drive and crawling under and over downed trees, we were able to make it to the road that led to the highway. To our dismay, it was also covered with huge trees. Even if we were able to clear the drive, the road to the highway was blocked, too.
There was no way to leave except by boat. We had no equipment (or the skill) to move such huge trees. We could only pick up small branches in our yard, but that seemed pointless. We knew that hundreds of other families were experiencing the same devastation. Neither one of us had experienced such a storm or such damage to our own property. We were discouraged and confused.
In another hour, though, things began to change. Across the creek, we could hear chain saws cutting through fallen trees. We met our next door neighbor coming up our shared drive. He had been working when the storm hit, but he had parked a mile away and hiked up to his house, crawling over and around snapped trees. He told me other neighbors—who did have the right equipment-- were already working to push aside the massive trees that had fallen on the road. In a few hours, they hoped to cut their way to our drive and begin clearing a path for us, as well. Perhaps we would not need to escape by boat after all..
As I reflected on this experience later, it occurred to me that it is possible to imagine two very different conceptions of God emerging from the storm. The first is the traditional conception of God, an omnipotent being who had become a powerful wind, passing over a village and punishing those who had offended him. Imagine pre-scientific humans, trying to understand such sudden and localized devastation. It would have been natural to assume a god was angry about something. Perhaps the damage would have been so great that the story of the storm would be told over campfires and repeated year after year, perhaps becoming part of the cultural history of the tribe. Over the generations, the story would evolve into a comprehensible legend. Perhaps a pillar of fire would be added at some point, as well as a description of the events that supposedly led up to it.. The legend would make a powerful point about what kind of behavior is offensive to the gods – perhaps even to the God of the Old Testament.
The other conception of God that emerges from the storm is one that makes sense to modern humans who realize powerful winds are not divinely inspired. Within hours of the storm, neighbors were helping each other recover. People were working side by side in the hot, humid air, cutting a path to each other’s doors because it was the right thing to do. There was genuine unqualified compassion for each other, even among those who had never met. No, it will not be permanent, and we will probably drift back to our own patios and boats, and simply wave to each other now and then. But we had the great privilege of seeing others pursue the highest value to which we can aspire. We can think of that highest ideal as God, and loving God as acting on it. Just as our ancestors drew lessons from powerful storms, we can as well.
There was no way to leave except by boat. We had no equipment (or the skill) to move such huge trees. We could only pick up small branches in our yard, but that seemed pointless. We knew that hundreds of other families were experiencing the same devastation. Neither one of us had experienced such a storm or such damage to our own property. We were discouraged and confused.
In another hour, though, things began to change. Across the creek, we could hear chain saws cutting through fallen trees. We met our next door neighbor coming up our shared drive. He had been working when the storm hit, but he had parked a mile away and hiked up to his house, crawling over and around snapped trees. He told me other neighbors—who did have the right equipment-- were already working to push aside the massive trees that had fallen on the road. In a few hours, they hoped to cut their way to our drive and begin clearing a path for us, as well. Perhaps we would not need to escape by boat after all..
As I reflected on this experience later, it occurred to me that it is possible to imagine two very different conceptions of God emerging from the storm. The first is the traditional conception of God, an omnipotent being who had become a powerful wind, passing over a village and punishing those who had offended him. Imagine pre-scientific humans, trying to understand such sudden and localized devastation. It would have been natural to assume a god was angry about something. Perhaps the damage would have been so great that the story of the storm would be told over campfires and repeated year after year, perhaps becoming part of the cultural history of the tribe. Over the generations, the story would evolve into a comprehensible legend. Perhaps a pillar of fire would be added at some point, as well as a description of the events that supposedly led up to it.. The legend would make a powerful point about what kind of behavior is offensive to the gods – perhaps even to the God of the Old Testament.
The other conception of God that emerges from the storm is one that makes sense to modern humans who realize powerful winds are not divinely inspired. Within hours of the storm, neighbors were helping each other recover. People were working side by side in the hot, humid air, cutting a path to each other’s doors because it was the right thing to do. There was genuine unqualified compassion for each other, even among those who had never met. No, it will not be permanent, and we will probably drift back to our own patios and boats, and simply wave to each other now and then. But we had the great privilege of seeing others pursue the highest value to which we can aspire. We can think of that highest ideal as God, and loving God as acting on it. Just as our ancestors drew lessons from powerful storms, we can as well.
Wednesday, July 8, 2009
Is God a Form of Energy?
Polls show that a growing number of Americans do not accept the traditional conception of God described in the Bible. For those that reach this point, the question is: what now? One possibility is to forget about the idea of God altogether. But, if one wants to keep God in his life, it is necessary to rethink one’s conception. In The Uncertain Believer, I suggest what I think is the most persuasive way to view God, but it useful to review a number of other possibilities.
I have heard a number of people suggest recently that they view God as a “divine life force” or a form of “spiritual energy,” perhaps emanating from the universe beyond earth, from a particular place or object, or even from another person, for example, someone who is about to die. As many have argued, humans have always decided what God is. There is nothing wrong with that; we just need to understand what we are doing. The question is what is intellectually persuasive and meaningful for our lives. If one finds meaning in viewing God as a form of divine or spiritual energy, then he has found the right path for himself.
There are several problems with such an idea, however. First, is the energy “supernatural,” that is, a form of energy never observed or confirmed by science? If that is the idea, this conception of God returns us to the mindset of our pre-scientific ancestors, visualizing a God that is purely the product of imagination. We might as well imagine emanations of energy from trees and rocks in the same way that pre-scientific humans viewed natural objects as divine. For example, among the magnificent rock formation near Sedona, Arizona, it is possible to visit spots that are claimed to be “energy vortexes” discovered by Indians centuries ago. Tourists hike to these spots, and having convinced themselves that they are going to feel a surge of energy when they get there, they do! The reality is that they are probably experiencing a surge of emotion based on anticipation, just as our pre-scientific ancestors’ emotions were heightened when they approached objects they considered sacred or divine.
On the other hand, if we are attracted by the idea of God as a type of energy confirmed by scientific observations, we have to imagine a God that is some aspect of the electromagnetic spectrum, alongside visible light, X-rays, gamma rays, and so on. That God is certainly real and we do not have to convince ourselves that such a God exists. The problem is figuring out how to love such a God. We can be impressed with radiation, but it makes no sense to be committed to it or feel that it plays a meaningful part in our life.
Finally, there is a problem with both notions of God as divine energy. How does it provide a framework for living? How does it help strengthen our relationships or make our lives more meaningful? In the end, we are left with an undirected mysticism, that takes us wherever we want. We might as well have forgotten the idea of God altogether.
I have heard a number of people suggest recently that they view God as a “divine life force” or a form of “spiritual energy,” perhaps emanating from the universe beyond earth, from a particular place or object, or even from another person, for example, someone who is about to die. As many have argued, humans have always decided what God is. There is nothing wrong with that; we just need to understand what we are doing. The question is what is intellectually persuasive and meaningful for our lives. If one finds meaning in viewing God as a form of divine or spiritual energy, then he has found the right path for himself.
There are several problems with such an idea, however. First, is the energy “supernatural,” that is, a form of energy never observed or confirmed by science? If that is the idea, this conception of God returns us to the mindset of our pre-scientific ancestors, visualizing a God that is purely the product of imagination. We might as well imagine emanations of energy from trees and rocks in the same way that pre-scientific humans viewed natural objects as divine. For example, among the magnificent rock formation near Sedona, Arizona, it is possible to visit spots that are claimed to be “energy vortexes” discovered by Indians centuries ago. Tourists hike to these spots, and having convinced themselves that they are going to feel a surge of energy when they get there, they do! The reality is that they are probably experiencing a surge of emotion based on anticipation, just as our pre-scientific ancestors’ emotions were heightened when they approached objects they considered sacred or divine.
On the other hand, if we are attracted by the idea of God as a type of energy confirmed by scientific observations, we have to imagine a God that is some aspect of the electromagnetic spectrum, alongside visible light, X-rays, gamma rays, and so on. That God is certainly real and we do not have to convince ourselves that such a God exists. The problem is figuring out how to love such a God. We can be impressed with radiation, but it makes no sense to be committed to it or feel that it plays a meaningful part in our life.
Finally, there is a problem with both notions of God as divine energy. How does it provide a framework for living? How does it help strengthen our relationships or make our lives more meaningful? In the end, we are left with an undirected mysticism, that takes us wherever we want. We might as well have forgotten the idea of God altogether.
Friday, June 26, 2009
What Does God Have to Do With Governor Sanford’s Affair?
Senator John Ensign of Nevada, Governor Mark Sanford of South Carolina, and Senator David Vitter of Louisiana are all professed Christian conservatives. Yet Ensign and Sanford recently admitted having extra-marital affairs and Vitter admitted visiting a prostitute. Senator Larry Craig, a religious conservative from Idaho, denied trying to have sex with a man in a bathroom stall but the evidence suggests otherwise. Despite claiming to be deeply religious, reality show stars Jon and Kate are getting a divorce and Jon reportedly had an affair with a third grade teacher. A USA Today column asks if Christian conservatives were seduced by the two, who “appeared flagrantly Christian: wearing Scripture-slogan shirts; speaking at churches, citing their faith for their refusal to pursue embryo-reduction for a safer, smaller pregnancy.”
Conservatives do not have a monopoly on extra-marital affairs, of course. The current and former governors of New York and John Edwards are examples of Democrats engaging in similar behavior. A reasonable assumption is that the rate at which people deal with their sexuality in destructive ways is the same for liberals and conservatives. Still, there seems to be something particularly hypocritical, or least paradoxical, when conservatives violate so blatantly the rules of conduct they have trumpeted so loudly. But, is there any inconsistency between these kinds of affairs and religious values? Does God have anything to do with Governor Sanford’s affair?
According to Sanford it does: He said at his press conference admitting the affair: “I am here because if you were to look at God’s laws, they are in every instance designed to protect people from themselves. It’s not a moral, rigid list of do’s and don’ts, just for the heck of do’s and don’ts. It is, indeed, to protect us from ourselves.” The idea seems to be that humans are weak and that there are certain kinds of conduct – unfortunately, they often are very pleasurable – that are self-destructive. God does not want us to engage in these kinds of conduct because they are bad for us. The image is that God is a parent and we are children. If we only learn the rules and comply with them, we will not get ourselves in trouble.
There are two problems with this formulation. The first problem is the idea of the rule book itself. It is not obvious what conduct is against the rules and, as practical matter, it is often a zealous majority, not God, who comes up with rules of conduct. That in turn can lead to laws that regulate our private lives, from what we read to what we do in bed with a consenting adult partner. The second problem with Sanford’s formulation is that it suggests the most important consideration is one’s own welfare, or in his words, “[protecting] people from themselves.” That is fundamentally different from what Jesus taught, of course. Recall Jesus’ famous answer to the rabbis who tried to trap him by asking him to identify the most important commandment. Jesus responded with two laws, not one: Love God and love your neighbor as yourself. That is a remarkably modern and insightful formulation that has nothing to do with dietary laws or rituals or particular rules about sexuality. It puts others first, not ourselves.
In The Uncertain Believer, I argue that those two “laws” are really different ways of saying the same thing. Once modern humans begin to think of God as the central unifying idea of unqualified compassion for others rather than the powerful being imagined by our pre-scientific answers, it makes no sense to talk about “God’s laws.” God has no “law” against adultery or even against having sex with someone in a bathroom stall. However, loving God in the sense of committing ourselves to the idea of compassion for others means that there is a “law” – or at least a principle – that we should not inflict pain on our families through selfish and irresponsible behavior.
It is certainly possible to have sympathy for Governor Sanford as an ordinary, flawed human being after listening to his rambling press conference. Feeling a powerful urge to have sex outside of marriage is common and millions have acted on that urge in foolish and destructive ways. But Sanford did not violate one of God’s laws by failing to protect himself. In my view, he failed to love God by failing to be compassionate with his family. Jesus would have said that he violated one of the two great laws for living. A modern view would be that these two laws merge into one unifying idea that we should always be compassionate and loving toward others. That very simple but very powerful idea gives us a framework for living. However one chooses to formulate it, the important point is that we see there is a relationship between God and our sexuality, just as there is between God and the rest our lives. If God is important to us, we commit ourselves to the principle of compassion for others, starting with our families.
Conservatives do not have a monopoly on extra-marital affairs, of course. The current and former governors of New York and John Edwards are examples of Democrats engaging in similar behavior. A reasonable assumption is that the rate at which people deal with their sexuality in destructive ways is the same for liberals and conservatives. Still, there seems to be something particularly hypocritical, or least paradoxical, when conservatives violate so blatantly the rules of conduct they have trumpeted so loudly. But, is there any inconsistency between these kinds of affairs and religious values? Does God have anything to do with Governor Sanford’s affair?
According to Sanford it does: He said at his press conference admitting the affair: “I am here because if you were to look at God’s laws, they are in every instance designed to protect people from themselves. It’s not a moral, rigid list of do’s and don’ts, just for the heck of do’s and don’ts. It is, indeed, to protect us from ourselves.” The idea seems to be that humans are weak and that there are certain kinds of conduct – unfortunately, they often are very pleasurable – that are self-destructive. God does not want us to engage in these kinds of conduct because they are bad for us. The image is that God is a parent and we are children. If we only learn the rules and comply with them, we will not get ourselves in trouble.
There are two problems with this formulation. The first problem is the idea of the rule book itself. It is not obvious what conduct is against the rules and, as practical matter, it is often a zealous majority, not God, who comes up with rules of conduct. That in turn can lead to laws that regulate our private lives, from what we read to what we do in bed with a consenting adult partner. The second problem with Sanford’s formulation is that it suggests the most important consideration is one’s own welfare, or in his words, “[protecting] people from themselves.” That is fundamentally different from what Jesus taught, of course. Recall Jesus’ famous answer to the rabbis who tried to trap him by asking him to identify the most important commandment. Jesus responded with two laws, not one: Love God and love your neighbor as yourself. That is a remarkably modern and insightful formulation that has nothing to do with dietary laws or rituals or particular rules about sexuality. It puts others first, not ourselves.
In The Uncertain Believer, I argue that those two “laws” are really different ways of saying the same thing. Once modern humans begin to think of God as the central unifying idea of unqualified compassion for others rather than the powerful being imagined by our pre-scientific answers, it makes no sense to talk about “God’s laws.” God has no “law” against adultery or even against having sex with someone in a bathroom stall. However, loving God in the sense of committing ourselves to the idea of compassion for others means that there is a “law” – or at least a principle – that we should not inflict pain on our families through selfish and irresponsible behavior.
It is certainly possible to have sympathy for Governor Sanford as an ordinary, flawed human being after listening to his rambling press conference. Feeling a powerful urge to have sex outside of marriage is common and millions have acted on that urge in foolish and destructive ways. But Sanford did not violate one of God’s laws by failing to protect himself. In my view, he failed to love God by failing to be compassionate with his family. Jesus would have said that he violated one of the two great laws for living. A modern view would be that these two laws merge into one unifying idea that we should always be compassionate and loving toward others. That very simple but very powerful idea gives us a framework for living. However one chooses to formulate it, the important point is that we see there is a relationship between God and our sexuality, just as there is between God and the rest our lives. If God is important to us, we commit ourselves to the principle of compassion for others, starting with our families.
Thursday, June 18, 2009
A Robin’s Nest Tragedy
Three weeks ago, my wife discovered a robin’s nest on the window sill outside our guest bedroom window. One morning, there were four perfectly shaped blue eggs. We were incredibly excited to have such a wonderful view of the nest. I had visions of taking pictures of the entire process, from the eggs hatching to the baby birds leaving the nest.
It was difficult to get a picture of the mother robin sitting on the nest. We learned that robins have sensitive hearing, and, if she heard noise through the window, she flew off. Her instinct is to escape from predators and leave the nest, even if the eggs are exposed. Most robins live only a year but those that grow to maturity can leave five years or more and lay eggs two or three times each season. Thus, it’s better for her to survive and lay eggs another day.
One morning there were only three eggs. We realized that this is was not going to be an entirely smooth process. While the nest was visible to us, it was also easily accessible to the neighborhood crows, which are natural predators. Still there were three eggs left and three days ago, they hatched! The baby birds were scrawny and pink, barely recognizable as birds, but we could see their little beaks reach up for food. Then two days ago, there were only two birds left. We were stunned. By the end of the day, there weren’t any! The mother bird never came back. The nest sits empty on the window sill. The entire brutal process in which predators, probably crows, ate the baby robins took less than twenty-four hours. A fortunate nest location for us turned out to be a bad mistake for the baby birds.
We talked about why we felt so bad. We agreed that we should not project human emotions on to the mother robin. Although the brain of a robin is large relative to its weight, it is still tiny compared to human brains. The robin brain has no complex limbic system, which generates and modulates emotions. It doesn’t make sense to say that the mother bird is “grieving.” The mother robin does not look for meaning when she loses all her babies to predators. She does not try to understand how this tragedy fits into a divine plan. Her instincts drive her to find a mate and lay eggs again, maybe in a few weeks. We understand that looking for a divine plan when crows eat baby birds is silly.
It is very difficult to accept the idea that we, like robins, lead lives filled with tragedies that make no sense. We want to find meaning when children die or when loving, generous friends are cut down by cancer. We want to believe that God works in mysterious ways and that there must be some overarching plan that is too complex for us to understand. Those who can find comfort in this vision are fortunate, and there is no need for them to find another path. But for those who cannot, the task is to find meaning despite the tragedies that strike all of us at one time or another. In The Uncertain Believer, I describe one path in which there is a central role for God, but in which there is no divine plan or belief in an anthropomorphic God that intervenes in the word. This is not a path for everyone, although I believe it is a good one for many. Whatever path one chooses, we can learn this lesson from the robin: There will be tragedies, but we can live for another day.
It was difficult to get a picture of the mother robin sitting on the nest. We learned that robins have sensitive hearing, and, if she heard noise through the window, she flew off. Her instinct is to escape from predators and leave the nest, even if the eggs are exposed. Most robins live only a year but those that grow to maturity can leave five years or more and lay eggs two or three times each season. Thus, it’s better for her to survive and lay eggs another day.
One morning there were only three eggs. We realized that this is was not going to be an entirely smooth process. While the nest was visible to us, it was also easily accessible to the neighborhood crows, which are natural predators. Still there were three eggs left and three days ago, they hatched! The baby birds were scrawny and pink, barely recognizable as birds, but we could see their little beaks reach up for food. Then two days ago, there were only two birds left. We were stunned. By the end of the day, there weren’t any! The mother bird never came back. The nest sits empty on the window sill. The entire brutal process in which predators, probably crows, ate the baby robins took less than twenty-four hours. A fortunate nest location for us turned out to be a bad mistake for the baby birds.
We talked about why we felt so bad. We agreed that we should not project human emotions on to the mother robin. Although the brain of a robin is large relative to its weight, it is still tiny compared to human brains. The robin brain has no complex limbic system, which generates and modulates emotions. It doesn’t make sense to say that the mother bird is “grieving.” The mother robin does not look for meaning when she loses all her babies to predators. She does not try to understand how this tragedy fits into a divine plan. Her instincts drive her to find a mate and lay eggs again, maybe in a few weeks. We understand that looking for a divine plan when crows eat baby birds is silly.
It is very difficult to accept the idea that we, like robins, lead lives filled with tragedies that make no sense. We want to find meaning when children die or when loving, generous friends are cut down by cancer. We want to believe that God works in mysterious ways and that there must be some overarching plan that is too complex for us to understand. Those who can find comfort in this vision are fortunate, and there is no need for them to find another path. But for those who cannot, the task is to find meaning despite the tragedies that strike all of us at one time or another. In The Uncertain Believer, I describe one path in which there is a central role for God, but in which there is no divine plan or belief in an anthropomorphic God that intervenes in the word. This is not a path for everyone, although I believe it is a good one for many. Whatever path one chooses, we can learn this lesson from the robin: There will be tragedies, but we can live for another day.
Monday, June 8, 2009
Are We Making a Mistake Waiting for God-ot?
My wife and I recently watched a wonderful production of Waiting for Godot in New York with Nathan Lane and John Goodman. There are many possible interpretations of Samuel Beckett’s play, which has been recognized as one of the most important of the twentieth century. Beckett himself refused to say much about its deeper meaning. His typical comment was something like: “It is what it is. You figure it out.”
One of the most obvious ways to read the play is to identify Godot as God and assume the two men on the country road – Estragon and Vladimir -- are waiting to meet God at the end of their lives. (As is typically done in European productions, the actors in this production put the accent on the first syllable of Godot: “god´-oh”.) Thus, Godot is audibly identified with God throughout the play.
The human condition is that death is inevitable and “there is nothing to be done,” as the characters say several times. Death can come unexpectedly, seemingly with no reason. A local landowner, Pozzo, passes by with a servant, Lucky. Pozzo says: “Behind this veil of gentleness and peace, night is charging and will burst upon us – pop! – just when we least expect it. That’s how it is on this bitch of an earth.”
A young boy comes to tell Estragon and Vladimir that Godot will not come today but “surely tomorrow.” He describes Godot as having a white beard. Lucky describes a “personal God” as having a white beard. This is the conventional image of God but this is the God that never comes. The central mistake is to wait for a God who is going to lift our burdens at the end life rather than seeing God as a central part of our life. As a result, we can become spiritually paralyzed and fail to find the meaning in life that is possible now. The play concludes (with some lines omitted):
Vladimir: We’ll hang ourselves tomorrow. Unless Godot comes.
Estragon: And if he comes?
Valdimir: We’ll be saved….
Estragon: Well? Shall we go?...
Vladimir: Well? Shall we go?
Estragon: Yes, let’s go.
(Stage direction: They do not move.)
One of the most obvious ways to read the play is to identify Godot as God and assume the two men on the country road – Estragon and Vladimir -- are waiting to meet God at the end of their lives. (As is typically done in European productions, the actors in this production put the accent on the first syllable of Godot: “god´-oh”.) Thus, Godot is audibly identified with God throughout the play.
The human condition is that death is inevitable and “there is nothing to be done,” as the characters say several times. Death can come unexpectedly, seemingly with no reason. A local landowner, Pozzo, passes by with a servant, Lucky. Pozzo says: “Behind this veil of gentleness and peace, night is charging and will burst upon us – pop! – just when we least expect it. That’s how it is on this bitch of an earth.”
A young boy comes to tell Estragon and Vladimir that Godot will not come today but “surely tomorrow.” He describes Godot as having a white beard. Lucky describes a “personal God” as having a white beard. This is the conventional image of God but this is the God that never comes. The central mistake is to wait for a God who is going to lift our burdens at the end life rather than seeing God as a central part of our life. As a result, we can become spiritually paralyzed and fail to find the meaning in life that is possible now. The play concludes (with some lines omitted):
Vladimir: We’ll hang ourselves tomorrow. Unless Godot comes.
Estragon: And if he comes?
Valdimir: We’ll be saved….
Estragon: Well? Shall we go?...
Vladimir: Well? Shall we go?
Estragon: Yes, let’s go.
(Stage direction: They do not move.)
Monday, June 1, 2009
Is God More Like a Magician, Doctor or Teacher?
What job category best fits your conception of God? For our pre-scientific ancestors who wrote the Old Testament, God was like a very powerful magician. He could change the laws of nature to further his often mysterious purposes. For example, God gives Moses and Aaron the ability to throw down a staff before the Pharaoh and turn it into a snake. Exodus 7:8-10. A more violent show of power occurs when God enables Elijah to do battle with the prophets of Baal and eventually kill all 450 of them. I Kings 18. And, of course, his most far-reaching display of power was the creation of the universe itself. This God was not particularly loving and forgiving, but if you complied with his rules, his powers would be used on your side, not on your enemy’s.
With the advance of science, the typical conception of God has changed from God as a powerful magician to God as a divine doctor. Most people still think of God in anthropomorphic terms. They refer to God as “He” and imagine a God with a human-like personality. Recent surveys show an increasing number of people who refer to God a “higher power” but do not think of a personal God. Nevertheless, many in both groups think of God as a force that mitigates the pain of life. They rely on the idea of God to reduce the anxiety and stress of life. They look to God to give them comfort at a time of sorrow, such as the death of a loved one. Most of all, they imagine a God who gives eternal life and, thus, provides a means to escape the ultimate pain of death.
I do not want to diminish this role of God as doctor. Millions of people derive enormous comfort from this idea of God, particularly in times of tragedy. However, the paradigm of God as doctor has two major limitations. First, the reduction in suffering is often temporary. A spiritual experience may be comforting, even exhilarating, but the pain of life returns after it is over. God as doctor does not provide a permanent framework for living. Second, many find it hard to accept the assumptions required to experience this escape from suffering, particularly the beautiful vision of life after death. Those who cannot accept this vision must deal with the eventual end of existence, not just their own own, but that of their loved ones.
I want to suggest a third job category: God as teacher. I do not mean God is a divine being who functions as a cosmic professor. Instead, imagine God as a source of ideas and attitudes. In this conception, God does not eliminate suffering, at least directly. Like teachers in real life, God imposes obligations and demands, namely that we live up to a set of standards. It may be that when we live up to those standards, or come as close as we can, we find the burdens of life are lifted. But that is because we discovered how to lift them ourselves. Perhaps it is more accurate to say that God is wisdom, and we are students who have to be our own teachers, too. In that way, we are not much different from the followers of Jesus, who was after all a teacher himself. What is John 3:16 if not the most important lesson in all of human history?
With the advance of science, the typical conception of God has changed from God as a powerful magician to God as a divine doctor. Most people still think of God in anthropomorphic terms. They refer to God as “He” and imagine a God with a human-like personality. Recent surveys show an increasing number of people who refer to God a “higher power” but do not think of a personal God. Nevertheless, many in both groups think of God as a force that mitigates the pain of life. They rely on the idea of God to reduce the anxiety and stress of life. They look to God to give them comfort at a time of sorrow, such as the death of a loved one. Most of all, they imagine a God who gives eternal life and, thus, provides a means to escape the ultimate pain of death.
I do not want to diminish this role of God as doctor. Millions of people derive enormous comfort from this idea of God, particularly in times of tragedy. However, the paradigm of God as doctor has two major limitations. First, the reduction in suffering is often temporary. A spiritual experience may be comforting, even exhilarating, but the pain of life returns after it is over. God as doctor does not provide a permanent framework for living. Second, many find it hard to accept the assumptions required to experience this escape from suffering, particularly the beautiful vision of life after death. Those who cannot accept this vision must deal with the eventual end of existence, not just their own own, but that of their loved ones.
I want to suggest a third job category: God as teacher. I do not mean God is a divine being who functions as a cosmic professor. Instead, imagine God as a source of ideas and attitudes. In this conception, God does not eliminate suffering, at least directly. Like teachers in real life, God imposes obligations and demands, namely that we live up to a set of standards. It may be that when we live up to those standards, or come as close as we can, we find the burdens of life are lifted. But that is because we discovered how to lift them ourselves. Perhaps it is more accurate to say that God is wisdom, and we are students who have to be our own teachers, too. In that way, we are not much different from the followers of Jesus, who was after all a teacher himself. What is John 3:16 if not the most important lesson in all of human history?
Tuesday, May 26, 2009
A Thought Experiment About an Asteroid
Imagine the movie disaster scenario of a huge asteroid approaching the earth. In this case, however, assume that there is nothing we can do about it. The earth is doomed and within a few months all higher forms of life will be destroyed. What would we do? How would we feel?
Overwhelmingly, we would turn to our families and the people we care about, almost always with regret that we had not taken more time to demonstrate our love to them. The entire world would have the insight that people close to the end of their lives have: What matters most are the people who love us and whom we love. A collective cry would spread over the planet: “I wish I had been more loving to those around me.”
Some would spend time thinking about the significance of our species as a whole. We would search for meaning in the 100,000 years or so that homo sapiens has existed. We might ask: Is it a disaster for the universe that the human species is about to become extinct? We would realize that our extinction is no more disastrous than the extinction of intelligent species on other planets, an event that may have already occurred many times.
Could we leave behind something meaningful? For example, we might consider trying to communicate with intelligent civilizations and to contribute our scientific achievements to them. However, our scientists would tell us that the vast distances of the universe mean that other civilizations will probably never hear from us. Even if they receive our signals millions of light years from now, they will probably be so far advanced that we can teach them nothing.
The most likely audience for whatever lessons we could teach is the future intelligent species that might evolve on our own planet if anything is left of it. Perhaps we could bury books deep in the earth to give this civilization a head start on scientific advancement. But is that all we would have to leave behind? Is our technology our greatest achievement? Couldn’t we teach this future species something about a way of living that is most meaningful?
Perhaps we would hit upon the same insights in reflecting on our species that we do in reflecting on our own life: What is most important is to love others in our world. But we are also likely to have the same reaction about how well we have lived up to this principle. We would consider what our collective human community has done, how it has used its vast resources, what our governments spend time doing, and what motivates us to vote for political candidates. We would surely have our regrets.
Overwhelmingly, we would turn to our families and the people we care about, almost always with regret that we had not taken more time to demonstrate our love to them. The entire world would have the insight that people close to the end of their lives have: What matters most are the people who love us and whom we love. A collective cry would spread over the planet: “I wish I had been more loving to those around me.”
Some would spend time thinking about the significance of our species as a whole. We would search for meaning in the 100,000 years or so that homo sapiens has existed. We might ask: Is it a disaster for the universe that the human species is about to become extinct? We would realize that our extinction is no more disastrous than the extinction of intelligent species on other planets, an event that may have already occurred many times.
Could we leave behind something meaningful? For example, we might consider trying to communicate with intelligent civilizations and to contribute our scientific achievements to them. However, our scientists would tell us that the vast distances of the universe mean that other civilizations will probably never hear from us. Even if they receive our signals millions of light years from now, they will probably be so far advanced that we can teach them nothing.
The most likely audience for whatever lessons we could teach is the future intelligent species that might evolve on our own planet if anything is left of it. Perhaps we could bury books deep in the earth to give this civilization a head start on scientific advancement. But is that all we would have to leave behind? Is our technology our greatest achievement? Couldn’t we teach this future species something about a way of living that is most meaningful?
Perhaps we would hit upon the same insights in reflecting on our species that we do in reflecting on our own life: What is most important is to love others in our world. But we are also likely to have the same reaction about how well we have lived up to this principle. We would consider what our collective human community has done, how it has used its vast resources, what our governments spend time doing, and what motivates us to vote for political candidates. We would surely have our regrets.
Monday, May 18, 2009
Does God have a Divine Mind?
There is a powerful, perhaps instinctive, desire to imagine a God that has a human-like divine mind. Even those who have rejected an anthropomorphic, “personal” God still have a difficult time abandoning the idea that God is conscious of us. This conception of God as having the characteristic of consciousness is an ancient one. Pre-scientific humans conceived of the gods as spirits with human-like personalities. The gods of the ancient Greeks tended to toy with humans and use them for their own selfish purposes, but these gods certainly paid attention to what humans were doing. The Old Testament describes a God who listens to people and becomes angry with them, even when God appears as a pillar of fire or burning bush. Even Deists, who are willing to accept the idea of a God who sits on the sidelines of the universe and does not intervene in history, hold on to the notion that God is conscious of us and, at least in some sense, “loves” us.
In The Uncertain Believer, I suggest that we abandon the notion of a God that has a human-like awareness of us. I suggest that the most persuasive conception of God, the one that is most consistent with what science has shown us, is a God that we can love but that does not love us back. That is because this God is an idea, a central, unifying idea that can be shared throughout the world, and the universe if there are other intelligent beings who are capable of sharing it.
The implications of such a God are far-reaching. On the one hand, it means we that we have to give up the idea that God listens to our prayers and answers some of them. I suspect that loss may not be so devastating for most of us, since real life has taught us that most prayers, even by the worthy, appear to go unanswered. At the same time, this intellectual step is enormously liberating because we need no longer struggle with the conflicts between science and religion. We do not need to tie ourselves in intellectual knots trying to fathom the purposes of a divine mind. There is no need to compete with other religious traditions on the grounds that we are the true followers of God but others are not. Paradoxically, perhaps, God can be more meaningful to us if we stop trying to understand God’s purposes and concentrate on our own.
In The Uncertain Believer, I suggest that we abandon the notion of a God that has a human-like awareness of us. I suggest that the most persuasive conception of God, the one that is most consistent with what science has shown us, is a God that we can love but that does not love us back. That is because this God is an idea, a central, unifying idea that can be shared throughout the world, and the universe if there are other intelligent beings who are capable of sharing it.
The implications of such a God are far-reaching. On the one hand, it means we that we have to give up the idea that God listens to our prayers and answers some of them. I suspect that loss may not be so devastating for most of us, since real life has taught us that most prayers, even by the worthy, appear to go unanswered. At the same time, this intellectual step is enormously liberating because we need no longer struggle with the conflicts between science and religion. We do not need to tie ourselves in intellectual knots trying to fathom the purposes of a divine mind. There is no need to compete with other religious traditions on the grounds that we are the true followers of God but others are not. Paradoxically, perhaps, God can be more meaningful to us if we stop trying to understand God’s purposes and concentrate on our own.
Tuesday, May 12, 2009
Do We Still Need Missionary Work?
There was a time when the United States justified its involvement in the affairs of other countries, at least in part, by declaring that it wanted to advance the spread of Christianity. In explaining why the United States should annex the Philippines after the Spanish-American War, President McKinley is reported to have said: “There was nothing left for us to do but to take them all, and to educate the Filipinos, and uplift and civilize and Christianize them, and by God’s grace do the very best we could by them, as our fellow-men for whom Christ also died.” It is likely that spreading Christianity was a less important motivator than having a platform to expand commercial ties with Asia. Nevertheless, it was part of the justification for obtaining influence over the Philippines as well as many other countries, especially during the nineteenth century.
That rationale is completely gone now. I cannot recall a single Democrat or Republican trying to justify the invasion of Iraq on the grounds that some Muslims might be converted to Christianity. Sometimes we say that we want to “convert” Iraqis to democracy but that means the focus is political ideology, not religious belief. Perhaps that change reflects a good development: We are more humble about the superiority of our faith and we do not see spreading Christianity or any religion as the role of government.
Today, the role of advancing particular religions is largely left to private denominations. But what used to be thought of as the heart of “missionary work” – converting non-believers to Christianity – has declined in importance. Instead, most denominations focus on providing social services. For example, Catholic Charities is the largest private network of social services in the United States, perhaps in the world.
Is there any longer a role for organized religion to try to convert others to a particular set of doctrines? In some cases, e.g., drug addicts, religious faith may be the best road to recovery. But if others are comfortable in their own spiritual life, why are many denominations still determined to convert others to their beliefs? Are they convinced that their path is the only road to a meaningful life? Or is it because there is an inherent desire of organizations to increase membership roles and budgets? If it is the latter, is that kind of modern missionary work so different from private corporations that are intent on increasing sales?
That rationale is completely gone now. I cannot recall a single Democrat or Republican trying to justify the invasion of Iraq on the grounds that some Muslims might be converted to Christianity. Sometimes we say that we want to “convert” Iraqis to democracy but that means the focus is political ideology, not religious belief. Perhaps that change reflects a good development: We are more humble about the superiority of our faith and we do not see spreading Christianity or any religion as the role of government.
Today, the role of advancing particular religions is largely left to private denominations. But what used to be thought of as the heart of “missionary work” – converting non-believers to Christianity – has declined in importance. Instead, most denominations focus on providing social services. For example, Catholic Charities is the largest private network of social services in the United States, perhaps in the world.
Is there any longer a role for organized religion to try to convert others to a particular set of doctrines? In some cases, e.g., drug addicts, religious faith may be the best road to recovery. But if others are comfortable in their own spiritual life, why are many denominations still determined to convert others to their beliefs? Are they convinced that their path is the only road to a meaningful life? Or is it because there is an inherent desire of organizations to increase membership roles and budgets? If it is the latter, is that kind of modern missionary work so different from private corporations that are intent on increasing sales?
Monday, May 4, 2009
What Can the Uncertainty Principle Teach Us about Religious Tolerance?
In The Uncertain Believer, I suggest a world in which humanity shares a common conception of God. While that world may not exist for many centuries, if ever, there is value in imagining what such a world would be like. In the meantime, how can we move toward greater tolerance and understanding about conflicting religious beliefs?
We can gain some insights from the uncertainty principle. As originally formulated by Werner Eisenberg, a German physicist, in 1926, the uncertainty principle has a narrow technical meaning: It is impossible to determine precisely the simultaneous position and momentum of a subatomic particle, such as an electron. We can identify probability distributions, but we cannot be certain of both variables at the same time. If we extend this idea more broadly, we can say that there are some important aspects of life about which we can never be certain.
Tom Boyd, Professor of Religious Studies at the University of Oklahoma, suggests that this idea can be important in our understanding of God and the role religious beliefs play in our lives. I believe what he has in mind is something like the following: Imagine two categories of religious beliefs. The first includes broad unifying ideas, such as the existence of God, somehow conceived, and the fundamental ideals for which God stands, particularly the obligation to love one another. All major religious traditions share those principles and we can feel, if not absolutely certain about them, very confident. However, when we begin to examine a second category of beliefs, for example, doctrines about the afterlife, religious rituals, and the precise nature of God and Jesus, we see drastic differences among religious traditions. At the same time, as we reflect on these more specific beliefs, we should realize that we cannot be certain about the correctness of them.
For example, if we feel the doctrines of our particular faith are grounded in the Bible, are we sure we have interpreted the Bible correctly? Are we relying on the Bible or are we really adopting beliefs that were developed by authorities in the church centuries after the Bible was written? And if these beliefs really do seem grounded in the Bible, is the Bible a reliable authority for those beliefs in the first place? Or are we making the mistake of accepting value judgments made by societies that were far less morally and intellectually advanced than our own? All these problems should make us more uncertain about the “details” of our religious creeds. And that uncertainty in turn should lead to humility and restraint about the rightness of our own beliefs.
The good thing is that uncertainty about the specifics need not lessen the strength of our faith or the commitment we feel to the broad principles of our religious tradition. It can, however, lead us to be more tolerant and respectful of the religious traditions of others.
We can gain some insights from the uncertainty principle. As originally formulated by Werner Eisenberg, a German physicist, in 1926, the uncertainty principle has a narrow technical meaning: It is impossible to determine precisely the simultaneous position and momentum of a subatomic particle, such as an electron. We can identify probability distributions, but we cannot be certain of both variables at the same time. If we extend this idea more broadly, we can say that there are some important aspects of life about which we can never be certain.
Tom Boyd, Professor of Religious Studies at the University of Oklahoma, suggests that this idea can be important in our understanding of God and the role religious beliefs play in our lives. I believe what he has in mind is something like the following: Imagine two categories of religious beliefs. The first includes broad unifying ideas, such as the existence of God, somehow conceived, and the fundamental ideals for which God stands, particularly the obligation to love one another. All major religious traditions share those principles and we can feel, if not absolutely certain about them, very confident. However, when we begin to examine a second category of beliefs, for example, doctrines about the afterlife, religious rituals, and the precise nature of God and Jesus, we see drastic differences among religious traditions. At the same time, as we reflect on these more specific beliefs, we should realize that we cannot be certain about the correctness of them.
For example, if we feel the doctrines of our particular faith are grounded in the Bible, are we sure we have interpreted the Bible correctly? Are we relying on the Bible or are we really adopting beliefs that were developed by authorities in the church centuries after the Bible was written? And if these beliefs really do seem grounded in the Bible, is the Bible a reliable authority for those beliefs in the first place? Or are we making the mistake of accepting value judgments made by societies that were far less morally and intellectually advanced than our own? All these problems should make us more uncertain about the “details” of our religious creeds. And that uncertainty in turn should lead to humility and restraint about the rightness of our own beliefs.
The good thing is that uncertainty about the specifics need not lessen the strength of our faith or the commitment we feel to the broad principles of our religious tradition. It can, however, lead us to be more tolerant and respectful of the religious traditions of others.
Monday, April 27, 2009
Is God "Perfect"?
Most people would say God is “perfect,” but what do they mean? In the Old Testament, God loses his temper periodically, conveys a very human sense of jealousy, and allows innocent people to die needlessly. Recall the plagues that God heaped on Egypt to persuade the Pharaoh to release the Israelites from bondage. Each time, the Pharaoh appeared to be persuaded but he changed his mind. Finally, God sent an angel of death that killed the firstborn child of every Egyptian, from the firstborn of the Pharaoh himself to the firstborn of the “captive that was in the dungeon.” Exodus 12:29.
Why wouldn’t a perfect, omnipotent God simply change the Pharaoh’s mind? Why cause the series of plagues, which imposed suffering throughout Egypt and prolonged the captivity of the Jews? Even more puzzling, why kill the first born of even lowly Egyptians who had nothing to do with the Pharaoh’s decision? No modern reader, trying to be objective, could conclude that God was “perfect” in this story, at least by modern standards of morality. God is “perfect” in the Exodus story only in the sense that he reflects the image that the ancient Jews had of a perfect God: one that would impose massive suffering on the Egyptians in return for the massive suffering that the Egyptians had imposed on them.
We see a similar example of a less advanced culture creating its own standard of perfection in the eleventh century when St. Anselm, the Archbishop of Canterbury, published the ontological argument for the existence of a “perfect being.” In The Uncertain Believer, I explain the weaknesses in the ontological argument, but for now focus on the fact that St. Anselm was Archbishop during the First Crusade when innocent persons in the Middle East were slaughtered by European zealots intent on seizing the Holy Land in the name of Christianity. St. Anselm no doubt felt the perfect God sanctioned the Crusades. Today, we would say that the church tried to justify this violence in the name of God, but no “perfect” God could possibly have sanctioned it.
Three lessons emerge from these examples. The first is that humans have always decided how to conceive of God and what God stands for. That means our conception of God can change over time as we grow morally and intellectually. The second is that the essential characteristics of God reflect each society’s understanding of perfection. The ancient Jews conceived of the essential characteristics of God as including the power to impose suffering on the Egyptians. As modern humans, we can see that the essential characteristics of God have nothing to do with the power to control nature and destroy enemies. They have to do with the power to inspire us to be perfect humans beings, or as come as close to it as we can. Finally, we can see that the most sensible way to think of God is that God is the inspiration for our own perfection. In other words, it is our perfection, not God’s, that matters and it is our perfection that should be the focus of our efforts.
Why wouldn’t a perfect, omnipotent God simply change the Pharaoh’s mind? Why cause the series of plagues, which imposed suffering throughout Egypt and prolonged the captivity of the Jews? Even more puzzling, why kill the first born of even lowly Egyptians who had nothing to do with the Pharaoh’s decision? No modern reader, trying to be objective, could conclude that God was “perfect” in this story, at least by modern standards of morality. God is “perfect” in the Exodus story only in the sense that he reflects the image that the ancient Jews had of a perfect God: one that would impose massive suffering on the Egyptians in return for the massive suffering that the Egyptians had imposed on them.
We see a similar example of a less advanced culture creating its own standard of perfection in the eleventh century when St. Anselm, the Archbishop of Canterbury, published the ontological argument for the existence of a “perfect being.” In The Uncertain Believer, I explain the weaknesses in the ontological argument, but for now focus on the fact that St. Anselm was Archbishop during the First Crusade when innocent persons in the Middle East were slaughtered by European zealots intent on seizing the Holy Land in the name of Christianity. St. Anselm no doubt felt the perfect God sanctioned the Crusades. Today, we would say that the church tried to justify this violence in the name of God, but no “perfect” God could possibly have sanctioned it.
Three lessons emerge from these examples. The first is that humans have always decided how to conceive of God and what God stands for. That means our conception of God can change over time as we grow morally and intellectually. The second is that the essential characteristics of God reflect each society’s understanding of perfection. The ancient Jews conceived of the essential characteristics of God as including the power to impose suffering on the Egyptians. As modern humans, we can see that the essential characteristics of God have nothing to do with the power to control nature and destroy enemies. They have to do with the power to inspire us to be perfect humans beings, or as come as close to it as we can. Finally, we can see that the most sensible way to think of God is that God is the inspiration for our own perfection. In other words, it is our perfection, not God’s, that matters and it is our perfection that should be the focus of our efforts.
Monday, April 20, 2009
Looking for God in All the Wrong Places
It can be easy to look for God in the wrong places. I have in mind the search for God in short term, intense spiritual experiences that seem to bring incredible insights when they are happening, but lose all meaning when they are over. There is nothing wrong with being carried away by music, nature, physical intimacy or any one of hundreds of pleasurable experiences (assuming the source of the experience is legal). The problem is thinking these experiences alone can bring meaning to our lives.
Twenty-five years ago, Dr. Herbert Benson wrote a book called The Relaxation Response, which described the body’s responses to a state of deep relaxation and meditation. The mind remains alert but heart and breathing rates go down, blood pressure falls, and there can be a general reduction in anxiety. Benson argued that this is the state achieved by Hindus, Buddhists and other adherents of religious traditions which emphasize meditation.
There is nothing particularly “religious” about this state of relaxation, although it can inspire reflection about one’s life, including one’s religious beliefs. Benson suggested this state could be achieved in ways that have no religious component, for example, by finding a quiet place, relaxing and reciting a sound, such as “ommmm,” that reduces distracting thoughts. The state may be similar to what is achieved in religious services, through quiet reflection, through chanting, or listening to repetitious, simple musical sounds, such as gongs, or “New Age” music that is invariably in the background at spas.
The point is not to demean these efforts to achieve a relaxed state of meditation. They can be very beneficial, if only to achieve a temporary sense of physical relaxation and mental reinvigoration. They can even be inspiring and give one a sense of direction in life, if they reinforce a framework for living that already exists. If one is comfortable and at peace with one’s spiritual life based on long-term consideration and reflection, short-term intense spiritual experiences help one to focus on these spiritual underpinnings and feel them at a deeper level.
Most of us feel a swelling of pride and patriotism when we hear the Star Spangled Banner because we believe in the basic principles on which our country was founded, even if we disagree with particular policies. In the same way, if we have found principles for living that help us rise above the day to day challenges and disappointments, we can experience them and celebrate them at a more intense level through meditation and short-term, intense spiritual experiences.
But if those principles are not there, if there is no framework for living that brings meaning to our lives, short-term feelings of spirituality disappear as surely as the fragrance of flowers disappears when we leave the garden. In that case, finding a framework for living should be the first step. Fifteen minutes of being carried away by New Age music will not get us there.
Twenty-five years ago, Dr. Herbert Benson wrote a book called The Relaxation Response, which described the body’s responses to a state of deep relaxation and meditation. The mind remains alert but heart and breathing rates go down, blood pressure falls, and there can be a general reduction in anxiety. Benson argued that this is the state achieved by Hindus, Buddhists and other adherents of religious traditions which emphasize meditation.
There is nothing particularly “religious” about this state of relaxation, although it can inspire reflection about one’s life, including one’s religious beliefs. Benson suggested this state could be achieved in ways that have no religious component, for example, by finding a quiet place, relaxing and reciting a sound, such as “ommmm,” that reduces distracting thoughts. The state may be similar to what is achieved in religious services, through quiet reflection, through chanting, or listening to repetitious, simple musical sounds, such as gongs, or “New Age” music that is invariably in the background at spas.
The point is not to demean these efforts to achieve a relaxed state of meditation. They can be very beneficial, if only to achieve a temporary sense of physical relaxation and mental reinvigoration. They can even be inspiring and give one a sense of direction in life, if they reinforce a framework for living that already exists. If one is comfortable and at peace with one’s spiritual life based on long-term consideration and reflection, short-term intense spiritual experiences help one to focus on these spiritual underpinnings and feel them at a deeper level.
Most of us feel a swelling of pride and patriotism when we hear the Star Spangled Banner because we believe in the basic principles on which our country was founded, even if we disagree with particular policies. In the same way, if we have found principles for living that help us rise above the day to day challenges and disappointments, we can experience them and celebrate them at a more intense level through meditation and short-term, intense spiritual experiences.
But if those principles are not there, if there is no framework for living that brings meaning to our lives, short-term feelings of spirituality disappear as surely as the fragrance of flowers disappears when we leave the garden. In that case, finding a framework for living should be the first step. Fifteen minutes of being carried away by New Age music will not get us there.
Monday, April 13, 2009
Should We Worry about Trends in Religious Beliefs?
The cover article in Newsweek last week was entitled The End of Christian America, by Jon Meacham. The article discusses the most recent American Religious Identification Survey as well as some other recent survey data. There are three major trends in American society, all of which track those already further along in Europe: 1) the number of people who identify themselves as “Christians” has fallen; 2) the percentage of people who do not identify with any faith has increased, and at the same time there is a general decline in those who think “religion” is the answer to social problems; and 3) the number of people who describe themselves as “atheist” or “agnostic” has quadrupled since 1990 to 3.6 million.
Are any of these trends cause for concern? From the point of view of organized religion, they certainly are. At one level, it means fewer members, shrinking donations, and less-than-full churches each Sunday. On a more basic level, it means that those who are deeply committed to their faiths and who find that it is fundamental to their lives, regret that others are unable to find this same meaning in theirs.
It would be a great cause for concern if we became a nation of individuals who care only about conventional success and pleasure. It’s not that belief in God is necessary for one to be moral. Voltaire took that position but he was wrong. It is possible to follow a highly ethical code for living without relying on any conception of God or higher purpose. In general, however, a central, unifying idea that represents the most fundamental and important purpose in life makes possible a personal commitment to this higher purpose. Moreover, it serves as a way for us as a larger community to communicate that idea to each other and reinforce it. That is why we should keep the idea of God alive, even if we give up on the traditional conception of God described in the Bible.
Although organized religion is worried, the good news for American society as a whole is that people are not giving up on their search for something more fundamental than physical pleasure and material wealth. Although an increasing percentage of people (15%, including atheists, agnostics and those with no preference) do not identify with any religion, “faith” and “religion” in the context of the survey mean organized religion, not a personal search for meaning or belief in a conception of God that is different from the one in the Bible. One striking trend is that only 69.5% of people believe in a personal God, but 12.1% believe in an impersonal higher power. I suspect many of the people who describe themselves as agnostics, or even atheists, are also looking for some way to identify meaning in life that transcends what we see around us every day.
How should we label people who do not want to give up on the idea of God but do not accept the conception of God portrayed in the Old and New Testaments? I use the phrase “Uncertain Believer” in the title of my book because we can never be absolutely certain about the nature of God. Other terms work just as well. Whatever term we use, it describes a growing number of Americans.
Are any of these trends cause for concern? From the point of view of organized religion, they certainly are. At one level, it means fewer members, shrinking donations, and less-than-full churches each Sunday. On a more basic level, it means that those who are deeply committed to their faiths and who find that it is fundamental to their lives, regret that others are unable to find this same meaning in theirs.
It would be a great cause for concern if we became a nation of individuals who care only about conventional success and pleasure. It’s not that belief in God is necessary for one to be moral. Voltaire took that position but he was wrong. It is possible to follow a highly ethical code for living without relying on any conception of God or higher purpose. In general, however, a central, unifying idea that represents the most fundamental and important purpose in life makes possible a personal commitment to this higher purpose. Moreover, it serves as a way for us as a larger community to communicate that idea to each other and reinforce it. That is why we should keep the idea of God alive, even if we give up on the traditional conception of God described in the Bible.
Although organized religion is worried, the good news for American society as a whole is that people are not giving up on their search for something more fundamental than physical pleasure and material wealth. Although an increasing percentage of people (15%, including atheists, agnostics and those with no preference) do not identify with any religion, “faith” and “religion” in the context of the survey mean organized religion, not a personal search for meaning or belief in a conception of God that is different from the one in the Bible. One striking trend is that only 69.5% of people believe in a personal God, but 12.1% believe in an impersonal higher power. I suspect many of the people who describe themselves as agnostics, or even atheists, are also looking for some way to identify meaning in life that transcends what we see around us every day.
How should we label people who do not want to give up on the idea of God but do not accept the conception of God portrayed in the Old and New Testaments? I use the phrase “Uncertain Believer” in the title of my book because we can never be absolutely certain about the nature of God. Other terms work just as well. Whatever term we use, it describes a growing number of Americans.
Labels:
Agnostic,
Athiest,
Bible,
Christians,
Ethics,
Faith,
God,
Morals,
New Testament,
Old Testament
Monday, April 6, 2009
Overcoming Doctrinal Differences by Going Back to Basics
As the Obama Administration reaches out to Iran, it is useful to remind ourselves of the religious differences between Christianity and Judaism, the most prominent traditions in the United States, and Islam, the dominant tradition in the Middle East. To do that, we need to have a starting point for comparison. What do Christians and Jews believe? Already we have a problem because what many Christians might say is the most important tenet of their faith – the divinity of Jesus – is rejected by Jews. What exactly then is the “Judeo-Christian” tradition? Judaism arose in a world dominated by polytheism, not just Greek and Roman, but other strands from Persia and India. The great intellectual advance was to worship one God. At first, this probably meant that there is one God that is greater than all the others, but later the central idea became: There is one God period.
Jesus was raised as a Jew and probably thought of himself as a Jew when he died. The movement that came after him built on Jewish doctrine to identify him as the Messiah, but rewrote Jewish doctrine to proclaim Jesus as the Son of God, then later one aspect of God himself. Mohammed was also raised in a polytheistic culture in what is now Saudi Arabia some six hundred years after Jesus lived. He seized on this central insight that there is one God. When he wrote the Quran, he saw himself as reforming and perfecting Judaism and Christianity, not completely rejecting it. He recognized Abraham as the patriarch of this tradition as well as the prophets of the Old Testament. He acknowledged the life of Jesus and viewed him as a prophet, too.
In short, there is more that unites Jews, Christians and Muslims than divides them, if we stick with the basic principle advocated by their founders. There is one God that should serve as the core of our lives. The massive superstructure of creeds, tenets, rituals, and doctrinal differences that have emerged since then is what makes these religious traditions seems so different. That is why it is important to go back to basic principles and remember that it is humans who are responsible for the elaborate rules we associated with particular denominations, not God. Their proponents may claim support for them in the Bible, the Quran, or some other sacred document, but these were written by humans, too, no doubt inspired by their view of God but actually conceived by them.
As I argue in The Uncertain Believer, the way to overcome our doctrinal differences is to focus on a central unifying idea recognized by the founders of Judaism, Christianity and Islam: There is an ideal that is higher than ourselves, higher than day to day struggles. It is the inspiration for human perfection. It deserves our commitment and dedication. If we make that commitment, life will be the better for it, not just our own life, but all those we touch. That central idea is God. I have no doubt that President Obama and President Ahmadenijad will appeal to that same God the night before they eventually meet.
Jesus was raised as a Jew and probably thought of himself as a Jew when he died. The movement that came after him built on Jewish doctrine to identify him as the Messiah, but rewrote Jewish doctrine to proclaim Jesus as the Son of God, then later one aspect of God himself. Mohammed was also raised in a polytheistic culture in what is now Saudi Arabia some six hundred years after Jesus lived. He seized on this central insight that there is one God. When he wrote the Quran, he saw himself as reforming and perfecting Judaism and Christianity, not completely rejecting it. He recognized Abraham as the patriarch of this tradition as well as the prophets of the Old Testament. He acknowledged the life of Jesus and viewed him as a prophet, too.
In short, there is more that unites Jews, Christians and Muslims than divides them, if we stick with the basic principle advocated by their founders. There is one God that should serve as the core of our lives. The massive superstructure of creeds, tenets, rituals, and doctrinal differences that have emerged since then is what makes these religious traditions seems so different. That is why it is important to go back to basic principles and remember that it is humans who are responsible for the elaborate rules we associated with particular denominations, not God. Their proponents may claim support for them in the Bible, the Quran, or some other sacred document, but these were written by humans, too, no doubt inspired by their view of God but actually conceived by them.
As I argue in The Uncertain Believer, the way to overcome our doctrinal differences is to focus on a central unifying idea recognized by the founders of Judaism, Christianity and Islam: There is an ideal that is higher than ourselves, higher than day to day struggles. It is the inspiration for human perfection. It deserves our commitment and dedication. If we make that commitment, life will be the better for it, not just our own life, but all those we touch. That central idea is God. I have no doubt that President Obama and President Ahmadenijad will appeal to that same God the night before they eventually meet.
Monday, March 30, 2009
Faith v. Love: Two Paradigms for Living
Two of the most beautiful chapters in the Bible are the Twenty-third Psalm and First Corinthians 13. While many of us learned both as children, we may not have realized that they offer radically different views of what life should be about.
Recall the image created in the Twenty-third Psalm: a solitary person searching for guidance and comfort. The metaphor is man as sheep and God as shepherd. Man needs food, water and protection from enemies. The psalmist is completely alone. There are no references to society, to friends, even to family. The message is this: Our time on earth is lonely, frightening and painful, but if we have faith and follow God’s laws, the reward comes later when we are freed of our earthly struggles and “dwell in the House of the Lord forever.” Psalms 23:6. This was a message for a desperately poor and oppressed people, who expected to experience far more suffering than joy. It still resonates with many people today.
Contrast that view of life with the one described in I Corinthians 13. Faith is important but clearly secondary. The highest value is “charity” (in the King James version) or “love” (in the American Standard version). “And though I have the gift of prophecy, and understand all mysteries, and all knowledge; and though I have all faith, so that I could remove mountains, and have not charity, I am nothing.” I Corinthians 13:2. While the Twenty-third Psalm is inward looking, this poem could not be more outward looking. There is a very different framework for living, one that puts compassion for others above understanding of mysteries, even above faith.
In The Uncertain Believer, I argue that the God of the Old Testament is something like Zeus: jealous, temperamental, and occasionally unfair. I argue that we should no longer think of God as the anthropomorphic being imagined by our ancient ancestors. But, assume for a minute, that there is an omnipotent, omniscient God who is truly “perfect” and is drawing up principles for living. Where do you think He would put outward displays of homage and devotion, even belief in Him, on the priority list, compared to showing compassion for those around us? If I Corinthians 13 is a good guide, and I think it is, displays of worship and faith would be far down on this list, if they were on the list at all. He would more likely begin his guide for living with the way I Corinthians 13 ends: “And now abideth faith, hope, charity, but the greatest of these is charity.”
Recall the image created in the Twenty-third Psalm: a solitary person searching for guidance and comfort. The metaphor is man as sheep and God as shepherd. Man needs food, water and protection from enemies. The psalmist is completely alone. There are no references to society, to friends, even to family. The message is this: Our time on earth is lonely, frightening and painful, but if we have faith and follow God’s laws, the reward comes later when we are freed of our earthly struggles and “dwell in the House of the Lord forever.” Psalms 23:6. This was a message for a desperately poor and oppressed people, who expected to experience far more suffering than joy. It still resonates with many people today.
Contrast that view of life with the one described in I Corinthians 13. Faith is important but clearly secondary. The highest value is “charity” (in the King James version) or “love” (in the American Standard version). “And though I have the gift of prophecy, and understand all mysteries, and all knowledge; and though I have all faith, so that I could remove mountains, and have not charity, I am nothing.” I Corinthians 13:2. While the Twenty-third Psalm is inward looking, this poem could not be more outward looking. There is a very different framework for living, one that puts compassion for others above understanding of mysteries, even above faith.
In The Uncertain Believer, I argue that the God of the Old Testament is something like Zeus: jealous, temperamental, and occasionally unfair. I argue that we should no longer think of God as the anthropomorphic being imagined by our ancient ancestors. But, assume for a minute, that there is an omnipotent, omniscient God who is truly “perfect” and is drawing up principles for living. Where do you think He would put outward displays of homage and devotion, even belief in Him, on the priority list, compared to showing compassion for those around us? If I Corinthians 13 is a good guide, and I think it is, displays of worship and faith would be far down on this list, if they were on the list at all. He would more likely begin his guide for living with the way I Corinthians 13 ends: “And now abideth faith, hope, charity, but the greatest of these is charity.”
Monday, March 23, 2009
How Would Jesus Feel?
Almost everyone has heard a Christian propose answering a difficult problem by asking: “What would Jesus do?” In many cases, that is a useful starting point, but it has its limitations. For one thing, if we have in mind the actual historical Jesus, we have to understand the context of his life. Even though he was remarkably progressive and insightful for his time, he was a wandering rabbi in a desperately poor society, with many of the superstitions, biases and intellectual limitations of his culture. Like most Jews, he believed an apocalypse was near, probably within a generation or two. (The Gospel of Mark records Jesus as telling listeners that some of them will not experience death but will see the Kingdom of God. Mark 9:1.) Admonitions to listeners to sell all their goods and give them to the poor have to be understood with this apocalyptic vision in mind.
A second problem is this: Figuring out what Jesus would do is difficult in the case of modern problems. What would Jesus do about sending more troops to Afghanistan, taxing the bonuses to AIG employees, or bailing out the auto industry? Still, this can be useful question if we can capture the timeless principle involved. I suggest backing up one step and asking: “How would Jesus feel?” Again, it doesn’t make sense to be too literal and speculate about what the historical Jesus would feel about any question – whether it is the role of women, homosexuality, pre-marital sex, or anything else. Instead, we should apply the central message of Jesus: loving God and loving our neighbors are the highest laws of life. This message then becomes a guide for a basic perspective on life. As I explain in The Uncertain Believer, committing ourselves to a principle of compassion for others gives us a framework for living. Asking how Jesus would feel is a metaphor to remind ourselves about the importance of starting from a compassionate perspective.
Committing ourselves to the principle of compassion still doesn’t give us complete answers to what we should do about Afghanistan, AIG or the auto industry although it does provide a starting point. For more personal questions – how should I treat my spouse, my children, my co-workers -- it can take us very far toward the answer. It’s a good bet that today one or more of the following will happen: someone will say something offensive to you, someone will treat you unfairly, or someone will need your help. In the few seconds you have to figure out how to respond, try asking: How would Jesus feel?
A second problem is this: Figuring out what Jesus would do is difficult in the case of modern problems. What would Jesus do about sending more troops to Afghanistan, taxing the bonuses to AIG employees, or bailing out the auto industry? Still, this can be useful question if we can capture the timeless principle involved. I suggest backing up one step and asking: “How would Jesus feel?” Again, it doesn’t make sense to be too literal and speculate about what the historical Jesus would feel about any question – whether it is the role of women, homosexuality, pre-marital sex, or anything else. Instead, we should apply the central message of Jesus: loving God and loving our neighbors are the highest laws of life. This message then becomes a guide for a basic perspective on life. As I explain in The Uncertain Believer, committing ourselves to a principle of compassion for others gives us a framework for living. Asking how Jesus would feel is a metaphor to remind ourselves about the importance of starting from a compassionate perspective.
Committing ourselves to the principle of compassion still doesn’t give us complete answers to what we should do about Afghanistan, AIG or the auto industry although it does provide a starting point. For more personal questions – how should I treat my spouse, my children, my co-workers -- it can take us very far toward the answer. It’s a good bet that today one or more of the following will happen: someone will say something offensive to you, someone will treat you unfairly, or someone will need your help. In the few seconds you have to figure out how to respond, try asking: How would Jesus feel?
Monday, March 16, 2009
A Thought Experiment about Constantine
The Roman Emperor Constantine became a Christian in 312 A.D. and legalized Christian worship the next year. His endorsement of Christianity set the stage for the Council of Nicea in 325, which declared Jesus to be divine and co-eternal with God. Emperor Theodosius issued a decree in 380 making Christianity the official religion of the Roman Empire and the Council of Rome approved the books of the Old and New Testament in 382.
There is nothing like the power of the state (an emperor no less) to grow your organization. From a fringe religion, subject to persecution by Roman emperors, Christianity became the dominant religion of Europe within a span of 70 years. The Great Schism that broke apart Catholicism, the Reformation, and the proliferation of Protestant denominations meant that Christianity would no longer be a unified movement under a European Pope. However, the basic elements of Christianity had fallen into place by the end of the fourth century and remain with us today.
Let’s do a thought experiment and imagine that Constantine had decided he didn’t want to become a Christian after all. Reportedly, he had a dramatic experience in 312 at the Battle of Milvian Bridge when he looked at the sun and saw a Christian cross. If the battle had gone badly, things might have been different. Imagine that, without the endorsement of Constantine, Christianity continued to exist but was only one of hundreds of other religious movements. Consequently, the Catholic Church never became the powerful source of Christian doctrine with the power of the state behind it. As a result, imagine that we in the twenty-first century feel free to study many religious traditions, both in Europe and in other parts of the world, and develop our own ideas about God. What would we decide?
We would probably maintain the core idea of monotheism, inherited from Judaism. We might study the life of Jesus and conclude that he was remarkably progressive and insightful for his time. Although he never disavowed Judaism, he stressed that the most important principles of life have nothing to do with dietary laws or rituals. Instead, these highest principles are to love God and love our neighbor. Perhaps we would be attracted to ideas of the Buddha, which focus on finding meaning by overcoming the desire for material pleasures. We might choose to borrow from Mohammed and passages in the Quran about social justice. We might be interested in the beliefs of indigenous peoples in the Americas regarding the sanctity of nature.
Above all, I think we would conclude that there should be a central unifying idea that conveys the highest purpose in life. I believe we would say that this highest purpose is reflected in Jesus’ statement about the importance of loving God and our neighbors. Out of a desire to continue the historical tradition of those who have gone before us, we could choose to call this central unifying idea God. Yet, we would not be bound by the images of God portrayed in the Bible by our pre-scientific ancestors. We would be free to take into account our vastly increased knowledge about science and the nature of the universe and think of God in a very different way.
This is more than an idle thought experiment, of course. It is the spiritual challenge we actually face. The number of Americans who say they have no religion is now 15%, up from 14.2 percent in 2001 and 8.2 percent in 1990, according to the American Religious Identification Survey. While some regions, such as the northern New England and the Pacific Northwest, have higher percentages of persons with no religion, the number of Americans with no religion rose in every state. Fewer Americans want a religious marriage or funeral. These percentages in Europe are already much higher. The numbers of persons abandoning religion will to continue to increase unless we move beyond doctrines that were developed in the fourth century and reconcile our beliefs about God with the science of the twenty-first century.
There is nothing like the power of the state (an emperor no less) to grow your organization. From a fringe religion, subject to persecution by Roman emperors, Christianity became the dominant religion of Europe within a span of 70 years. The Great Schism that broke apart Catholicism, the Reformation, and the proliferation of Protestant denominations meant that Christianity would no longer be a unified movement under a European Pope. However, the basic elements of Christianity had fallen into place by the end of the fourth century and remain with us today.
Let’s do a thought experiment and imagine that Constantine had decided he didn’t want to become a Christian after all. Reportedly, he had a dramatic experience in 312 at the Battle of Milvian Bridge when he looked at the sun and saw a Christian cross. If the battle had gone badly, things might have been different. Imagine that, without the endorsement of Constantine, Christianity continued to exist but was only one of hundreds of other religious movements. Consequently, the Catholic Church never became the powerful source of Christian doctrine with the power of the state behind it. As a result, imagine that we in the twenty-first century feel free to study many religious traditions, both in Europe and in other parts of the world, and develop our own ideas about God. What would we decide?
We would probably maintain the core idea of monotheism, inherited from Judaism. We might study the life of Jesus and conclude that he was remarkably progressive and insightful for his time. Although he never disavowed Judaism, he stressed that the most important principles of life have nothing to do with dietary laws or rituals. Instead, these highest principles are to love God and love our neighbor. Perhaps we would be attracted to ideas of the Buddha, which focus on finding meaning by overcoming the desire for material pleasures. We might choose to borrow from Mohammed and passages in the Quran about social justice. We might be interested in the beliefs of indigenous peoples in the Americas regarding the sanctity of nature.
Above all, I think we would conclude that there should be a central unifying idea that conveys the highest purpose in life. I believe we would say that this highest purpose is reflected in Jesus’ statement about the importance of loving God and our neighbors. Out of a desire to continue the historical tradition of those who have gone before us, we could choose to call this central unifying idea God. Yet, we would not be bound by the images of God portrayed in the Bible by our pre-scientific ancestors. We would be free to take into account our vastly increased knowledge about science and the nature of the universe and think of God in a very different way.
This is more than an idle thought experiment, of course. It is the spiritual challenge we actually face. The number of Americans who say they have no religion is now 15%, up from 14.2 percent in 2001 and 8.2 percent in 1990, according to the American Religious Identification Survey. While some regions, such as the northern New England and the Pacific Northwest, have higher percentages of persons with no religion, the number of Americans with no religion rose in every state. Fewer Americans want a religious marriage or funeral. These percentages in Europe are already much higher. The numbers of persons abandoning religion will to continue to increase unless we move beyond doctrines that were developed in the fourth century and reconcile our beliefs about God with the science of the twenty-first century.
Monday, March 9, 2009
What Does God Have to Do with Life on Other Planets?
Last week I called attention to a recent analysis by mathematicians at the University of Edinburgh, which estimated that there are hundreds of intelligent civilizations in our galaxy and thousands in the universe. This plausibility of this analysis is strengthened by the discovery that there may be 100 billion earth-like planets in our galaxy alone.
In response, the Chaldea blog on the Scholarly Study of Astronomy and Religion noted that the Vatican’s chief astronomer has said that there is no conflict between believing in God and the possibility of intelligent life on other planets, including beings more highly evolved than ourselves. "In my opinion this possibility exists," said the Reverend José Gabriel Funes, head of the Vatican Observatory and a scientific adviser to Pope Benedict XVI. “The large number of galaxies with their own planets makes this possible.”
It is encouraging that the Vatican acknowledges that there may be intelligent life on other planets. Does that mean that humans are not a special species, but simply the result of natural selection, along with potentially thousands of other intelligent civilizations? Both Pope John Paul II and Pope Benedict (as a Cardinal) made statements generally supportive of evolution. However, a 1996 statement by Pope John Paul takes the position that God controlled evolution of the human species, not that it proceeded solely on the basis of natural selection and random mutation of genetic material.
But if God controls evolution, has he intentionally created thousands of intelligent civilizations? Does God love all these intelligent beings equally? If so, has God revealed himself to all of them? Has some version of the Jesus story been repeated thousands of times through the universe? If not, why?
If we try to come up with answers that are consistent with Catholic doctrine, we may conclude that the intellectual gymnastics required to do so are not really worth it. Doesn’t it make more sense to have a different starting point and rethink our conception of God? If we imagine God as something other than an anthropomorphic being who created the universe and controlled evolution, we don’t have to invent implausible scenarios about divine intervention on thousands of planets. As I explain in The Uncertain Believer, we -- and other intelligent civilizations, if they really exist -- have the capacity to conceive of God as a power that inspires us to be as perfect as we can be, yet has nothing to do with evolution on this planet or any other.
In response, the Chaldea blog on the Scholarly Study of Astronomy and Religion noted that the Vatican’s chief astronomer has said that there is no conflict between believing in God and the possibility of intelligent life on other planets, including beings more highly evolved than ourselves. "In my opinion this possibility exists," said the Reverend José Gabriel Funes, head of the Vatican Observatory and a scientific adviser to Pope Benedict XVI. “The large number of galaxies with their own planets makes this possible.”
It is encouraging that the Vatican acknowledges that there may be intelligent life on other planets. Does that mean that humans are not a special species, but simply the result of natural selection, along with potentially thousands of other intelligent civilizations? Both Pope John Paul II and Pope Benedict (as a Cardinal) made statements generally supportive of evolution. However, a 1996 statement by Pope John Paul takes the position that God controlled evolution of the human species, not that it proceeded solely on the basis of natural selection and random mutation of genetic material.
But if God controls evolution, has he intentionally created thousands of intelligent civilizations? Does God love all these intelligent beings equally? If so, has God revealed himself to all of them? Has some version of the Jesus story been repeated thousands of times through the universe? If not, why?
If we try to come up with answers that are consistent with Catholic doctrine, we may conclude that the intellectual gymnastics required to do so are not really worth it. Doesn’t it make more sense to have a different starting point and rethink our conception of God? If we imagine God as something other than an anthropomorphic being who created the universe and controlled evolution, we don’t have to invent implausible scenarios about divine intervention on thousands of planets. As I explain in The Uncertain Believer, we -- and other intelligent civilizations, if they really exist -- have the capacity to conceive of God as a power that inspires us to be as perfect as we can be, yet has nothing to do with evolution on this planet or any other.
Monday, March 2, 2009
How Will the Church Respond to Discoveries about the Universe?
In 1543, Copernicus published his major work arguing that the earth revolves around the sun, rather than the reverse. The Catholic Church required modifications of his conclusions and placed Galileo under house arrest because he endorsed the idea of a heliocentric solar system. When Benjamin Franklin proposed erecting lightning rods on buildings, the Pastor of the Old South Church in Boston declared that there is no point in trying to resist God’s wrath in the form of lightning. And, when William Scopes taught science in a Tennessee high school in the 1920’s, he was prosecuted for violating a ban on teaching evolution, which had been passed at the urging of religious conservatives. Far too often, organized religion has been at odds with scientific discoveries because they conflict with religious doctrine. Rather than modify doctrine, the church attacks the scientists and their discoveries.
Science will continue to tell us more about the universe, and the church must decide how to respond. For example, a new book, The Crowded Universe: The Search for Living Planets, by Alan Boss, an astronomer with the Carnegie Institution, suggests that there may be 100 billion earth-like planets in our galaxy. If any of them have liquid water, they are likely to have some type of life. A recent computer model developed by researchers at the University of Edinburgh in Scotland estimates that at least 361 intelligent civilizations have emerged in our galaxy alone since the Big Bang. Across the universe, the model estimates that there are thousands.
Star Trek episodes have made us think that we can zip from one inhabited planet to another in a few days. However, if we stick with realistic assumptions about rocket ship speeds, traveling beyond our solar system to the nearest star would take about 100,000 years. Even if we develop the technology to make the trip, would we go? The trip would last about twenty times as long as recorded human history. The same limitations apply to other civilizations, which mean their inhabitants are not likely to come here either.
What are the implications of all this? Perhaps some day, we will hear a radio message from a distant planet that has traveled thousands of years at the speed of light to reach us. For practical purposes, however, we are alone in the universe, not because a supreme being created us as a special species, but because the distances in the universe are so vast that we will never be able to interact with other intelligent life. If our species becomes extinct, the Edinburgh analysis suggests that advanced civilizations will continue to flourish in the universe.
It would be helpful if organized religion could help us understand the significance of these findings and find a conception of God that is consistent with them. The odds are, however, that the church will urge us to ignore today’s scientists and mathematicians and to rely on the accounts in Genesis, which were written by people who thought the earth is flat and the sun goes around it.
Science will continue to tell us more about the universe, and the church must decide how to respond. For example, a new book, The Crowded Universe: The Search for Living Planets, by Alan Boss, an astronomer with the Carnegie Institution, suggests that there may be 100 billion earth-like planets in our galaxy. If any of them have liquid water, they are likely to have some type of life. A recent computer model developed by researchers at the University of Edinburgh in Scotland estimates that at least 361 intelligent civilizations have emerged in our galaxy alone since the Big Bang. Across the universe, the model estimates that there are thousands.
Star Trek episodes have made us think that we can zip from one inhabited planet to another in a few days. However, if we stick with realistic assumptions about rocket ship speeds, traveling beyond our solar system to the nearest star would take about 100,000 years. Even if we develop the technology to make the trip, would we go? The trip would last about twenty times as long as recorded human history. The same limitations apply to other civilizations, which mean their inhabitants are not likely to come here either.
What are the implications of all this? Perhaps some day, we will hear a radio message from a distant planet that has traveled thousands of years at the speed of light to reach us. For practical purposes, however, we are alone in the universe, not because a supreme being created us as a special species, but because the distances in the universe are so vast that we will never be able to interact with other intelligent life. If our species becomes extinct, the Edinburgh analysis suggests that advanced civilizations will continue to flourish in the universe.
It would be helpful if organized religion could help us understand the significance of these findings and find a conception of God that is consistent with them. The odds are, however, that the church will urge us to ignore today’s scientists and mathematicians and to rely on the accounts in Genesis, which were written by people who thought the earth is flat and the sun goes around it.
Monday, February 23, 2009
Reconciling Religion and Evolution, Cont.
In last week’s comment, I noted the passage of the two hundredth anniversary of Charles Darwin’s birth and the struggle to reconcile evolution with religious beliefs and the idea that humans are “special.” Because that question is so central to our understanding of the world, I return to it today. How do we resolve this problem? To get started, consider widely accepted facts about the origins and development of life.
The Big Bang occurred around 14 billion years ago, and earth was formed about ten billion years later. After another billion years or so, very primitive forms of life developed on earth and evolved into the vast array of plants and animals we see around us, including ourselves. Our earliest ancestors in the genus “homo,” homo habilis, probably developed around 2.4 million years ago, followed by homo erectus, which appeared about 1.8 million years ago. Our species, homo sapiens, has existed for perhaps 250,000 years. Two other members of the genus homo, Neanderthals and homo floresiensis, were probably branches off the evolutionary chain that led to homo sapiens. Homo erectus survived until around 70,000 years ago, and Neanderthals may have lived as recently as 30,000 years ago, before they became extinct. Homo floresiensis, may have developed after homo sapiens and become extinct as recently as twelve thousand years ago. In other words, the story of human evolution is one of development and extinction. Our vulnerability to disease, violence and climate change make it quite possible that some day we will also be extinct.
To their credit, The Catholic Church and some Protestant denominations have made a serious effort to find an accommodation between evolution and religion. Are they on the right track? The position of the Catholic Church appears to be that God controlled the process of evolution to create a special species, homo sapiens. The problem with that approach is the overwhelming scientific evidence that development of all species, including our own, has been driven by random mutation and natural selection. The process that led to homo sapiens is the same one that led to dinosaurs, birds, and earthworms.
The Church of England, on the other hand, appears to have accepted the full, unvarnished implications of evolution. It has devoted a section of its website to Darwin. An essay on the website explains its position:[1] "[While] it is not difficult to see why evolutionary thinking was offensive at the time, on reflection it is not such an earth-shattering idea. Yes, Christians believe that God became incarnate as a human being in the person of Jesus and thereby demonstrated God’s especial love for humanity. But how can that special relationship be undermined just because we develop a different understanding of the processes by which humanity came to be?"
Although that excerpt is somewhat ambiguous, I believe the author means that God had nothing to do with the process of evolution and, by implication, the creation of any living species. However, once God noticed that an intelligent species had evolved on earth, perhaps the only place that development occurred in the universe, he concluded that this species is special. He then decided to reveal himself to these creatures, get involved in their lives, and love them.
The Church of England should be commended for accepting the scientific evidence about how evolution has actually occurred. However, the Church’s account paints a strange picture of God as a supreme being who sits on the sidelines of the universe until natural selection happens to result in an intelligent species that warrants his involvement, at least after humans have been around for 250,000 years or so. He then decides to reveal himself as Jesus in order to show how much he cares for these beings. That conception of God is neither intellectually convincing nor emotionally satisfying.
Despite its sincere efforts, the approach of the Church of England will not help us to come to terms with development of human beings. We are not special because a divine mind made us the ultimate result of an evolutionary process, nor are we special because a supreme being noticed that we are an intelligent species worthy of his love. As I explain in The Uncertain Believer, we are special because we are the only species, on earth at least, with the capacity to understand our place in the universe. We are special because we have the ability to develop a conception of God that makes sense in the twenty-first century.
[1] Good Religion Needs Good Science,” by Rev Dr. Malcolm Brown, the Director of Mission and Public Affairs.
The Big Bang occurred around 14 billion years ago, and earth was formed about ten billion years later. After another billion years or so, very primitive forms of life developed on earth and evolved into the vast array of plants and animals we see around us, including ourselves. Our earliest ancestors in the genus “homo,” homo habilis, probably developed around 2.4 million years ago, followed by homo erectus, which appeared about 1.8 million years ago. Our species, homo sapiens, has existed for perhaps 250,000 years. Two other members of the genus homo, Neanderthals and homo floresiensis, were probably branches off the evolutionary chain that led to homo sapiens. Homo erectus survived until around 70,000 years ago, and Neanderthals may have lived as recently as 30,000 years ago, before they became extinct. Homo floresiensis, may have developed after homo sapiens and become extinct as recently as twelve thousand years ago. In other words, the story of human evolution is one of development and extinction. Our vulnerability to disease, violence and climate change make it quite possible that some day we will also be extinct.
To their credit, The Catholic Church and some Protestant denominations have made a serious effort to find an accommodation between evolution and religion. Are they on the right track? The position of the Catholic Church appears to be that God controlled the process of evolution to create a special species, homo sapiens. The problem with that approach is the overwhelming scientific evidence that development of all species, including our own, has been driven by random mutation and natural selection. The process that led to homo sapiens is the same one that led to dinosaurs, birds, and earthworms.
The Church of England, on the other hand, appears to have accepted the full, unvarnished implications of evolution. It has devoted a section of its website to Darwin. An essay on the website explains its position:[1] "[While] it is not difficult to see why evolutionary thinking was offensive at the time, on reflection it is not such an earth-shattering idea. Yes, Christians believe that God became incarnate as a human being in the person of Jesus and thereby demonstrated God’s especial love for humanity. But how can that special relationship be undermined just because we develop a different understanding of the processes by which humanity came to be?"
Although that excerpt is somewhat ambiguous, I believe the author means that God had nothing to do with the process of evolution and, by implication, the creation of any living species. However, once God noticed that an intelligent species had evolved on earth, perhaps the only place that development occurred in the universe, he concluded that this species is special. He then decided to reveal himself to these creatures, get involved in their lives, and love them.
The Church of England should be commended for accepting the scientific evidence about how evolution has actually occurred. However, the Church’s account paints a strange picture of God as a supreme being who sits on the sidelines of the universe until natural selection happens to result in an intelligent species that warrants his involvement, at least after humans have been around for 250,000 years or so. He then decides to reveal himself as Jesus in order to show how much he cares for these beings. That conception of God is neither intellectually convincing nor emotionally satisfying.
Despite its sincere efforts, the approach of the Church of England will not help us to come to terms with development of human beings. We are not special because a divine mind made us the ultimate result of an evolutionary process, nor are we special because a supreme being noticed that we are an intelligent species worthy of his love. As I explain in The Uncertain Believer, we are special because we are the only species, on earth at least, with the capacity to understand our place in the universe. We are special because we have the ability to develop a conception of God that makes sense in the twenty-first century.
[1] Good Religion Needs Good Science,” by Rev Dr. Malcolm Brown, the Director of Mission and Public Affairs.
Monday, February 16, 2009
Reconciling God and Evolution
Last Thursday was the 200th anniversary of Charles Darwin’s birth. The occasion prompted much commentary about the conflict between religion and evolution. As in the case of many scientific discoveries through history, much of organized religion resisted Darwin’s insights about natural seletion. Some conservative denominations still do.
One reaction to a clash between science and religious doctrines is to rethink the doctrines. However, the general response of organized religion has been to resist the findings of science until the facts become so overwhelming that religion has to give way. That process is underway now for evolution and will be underway some day for our understanding of creation itself.
In general, there are three broad approaches to reconciling God and evolution. One way is to reject the Darwinian conception of evolution altogether. For example, religious conservatives who endorse Intelligent Design deny that species develop through random mutation and natural selection. Instead, they argue that all species (and everything else in nature) are elements of a complex plan put into effect by a divine creator. That approach provides a beautiful and inspiring explanation of a complex organ such as the eye, but it has the weakness that it is radically inconsistent with the scientific evidence. The history of life on earth is a story of imperfect biological structures, millions of extinct species, and incremental development over billions of years. Real living things fall far short of an idealized Intelligent Design.
A second approach is to accept the basic elements of evolution but to argue that God put evolution in motion and somehow “controls” it. This preserves the conception of a divine creator God but it requires considerable intellectual gymnastics to reconcile the actual results of evolution with the benevolent control by God. Why would a loving God allow evolution to result in painful and debilitating genetic defects, a human body that allows cancer to destroy innocent children, and species, including our own, that are vulnerable to extinction? The problem with both approaches is that they are premised on the conception of God that we inherited from our pre-scientific ancestors. In other words, the challenge is not the conflict between God and evolution. It is how we think of God.
The third approach, and the one that makes the most sense, is to say that God has nothing to do with evolution. That is because God is not the anthropomorphic being that the authors of the Old Testament imagined. We should stop worrying about reconciling evolution with the notion that God created man in his own image. The truth is the reverse. Our pre-scientific ancestors created God in man’s image, whether they were the ancient Jews, the inventors of the Greek and Roman Gods, or the early Hindus who conceived of Vishnu and Krishna. In The Uncertain Believer, I explain that the essential characteristic of God is not the raw power to control nature and defeat enemies, the quality admired by our ancestors. The essential quality of God is the power to inspire us to be as perfect as can be. That leads to a very different view of God and one that is perfectly compatible with evolution and, indeed, with all of science.
One reaction to a clash between science and religious doctrines is to rethink the doctrines. However, the general response of organized religion has been to resist the findings of science until the facts become so overwhelming that religion has to give way. That process is underway now for evolution and will be underway some day for our understanding of creation itself.
In general, there are three broad approaches to reconciling God and evolution. One way is to reject the Darwinian conception of evolution altogether. For example, religious conservatives who endorse Intelligent Design deny that species develop through random mutation and natural selection. Instead, they argue that all species (and everything else in nature) are elements of a complex plan put into effect by a divine creator. That approach provides a beautiful and inspiring explanation of a complex organ such as the eye, but it has the weakness that it is radically inconsistent with the scientific evidence. The history of life on earth is a story of imperfect biological structures, millions of extinct species, and incremental development over billions of years. Real living things fall far short of an idealized Intelligent Design.
A second approach is to accept the basic elements of evolution but to argue that God put evolution in motion and somehow “controls” it. This preserves the conception of a divine creator God but it requires considerable intellectual gymnastics to reconcile the actual results of evolution with the benevolent control by God. Why would a loving God allow evolution to result in painful and debilitating genetic defects, a human body that allows cancer to destroy innocent children, and species, including our own, that are vulnerable to extinction? The problem with both approaches is that they are premised on the conception of God that we inherited from our pre-scientific ancestors. In other words, the challenge is not the conflict between God and evolution. It is how we think of God.
The third approach, and the one that makes the most sense, is to say that God has nothing to do with evolution. That is because God is not the anthropomorphic being that the authors of the Old Testament imagined. We should stop worrying about reconciling evolution with the notion that God created man in his own image. The truth is the reverse. Our pre-scientific ancestors created God in man’s image, whether they were the ancient Jews, the inventors of the Greek and Roman Gods, or the early Hindus who conceived of Vishnu and Krishna. In The Uncertain Believer, I explain that the essential characteristic of God is not the raw power to control nature and defeat enemies, the quality admired by our ancestors. The essential quality of God is the power to inspire us to be as perfect as can be. That leads to a very different view of God and one that is perfectly compatible with evolution and, indeed, with all of science.
Labels:
Bible,
Charles Darwin,
Creation,
Faith,
God,
Intelligent Design,
Nature,
Religion,
Science,
Universe
Monday, February 9, 2009
An (almost) Useless Debate about God on British Buses
The Washington Post reported last Friday that thousands of people in Christian groups in Britain raised money to place ads in buses to combat an advertising campaign by atheists. In theory, this kind of dialogue could be quite useful. One side might provide an intellectually provocative argument, and the other side would respond with something equally compelling. The rest of us on the sidelines (or sitting on the bus) could benefit from the exchange. Sadly, that is not the case.
Here is the type of exchanges that appear in the ads: The atheists' ads said: “There is probably no God. Now stop worrying and enjoy your life.” The Christian groups’ response was: “There definitely is a God.” Another: “The fool hath said in his heart, There is no God.” Do you get much out of that exchange?
The unstated premise in this back and forth is that the conception of God each side has in mind is the God we learned about as children in Sunday School. If the only possible meaning of the term “God” is something like the God described in the Old Testament, an anthropomorphic being who created the universe and intervenes in the world, then we are stuck in a bipolar world between atheists and traditional believers. In fact, as I explain in The Uncertain Believer, there are many ways to conceive of God. Some of the greatest thinkers in history from Aristotle to modern theologians have held conceptions of God that are very different from the one described in the Bible. It makes no sense to accept without question the conception advanced by our pre-scientific ancestors. With all due respect to the authors of the Old Testament, we have learned a lot since then.
The most important question for modern humans is how to think of God, once we see that we are free to rethink the conception of God we inherited from those who have gone before us. The arguments about these possibilities are provocative, even exciting. Now that would be a useful debate.
Here is the type of exchanges that appear in the ads: The atheists' ads said: “There is probably no God. Now stop worrying and enjoy your life.” The Christian groups’ response was: “There definitely is a God.” Another: “The fool hath said in his heart, There is no God.” Do you get much out of that exchange?
The unstated premise in this back and forth is that the conception of God each side has in mind is the God we learned about as children in Sunday School. If the only possible meaning of the term “God” is something like the God described in the Old Testament, an anthropomorphic being who created the universe and intervenes in the world, then we are stuck in a bipolar world between atheists and traditional believers. In fact, as I explain in The Uncertain Believer, there are many ways to conceive of God. Some of the greatest thinkers in history from Aristotle to modern theologians have held conceptions of God that are very different from the one described in the Bible. It makes no sense to accept without question the conception advanced by our pre-scientific ancestors. With all due respect to the authors of the Old Testament, we have learned a lot since then.
The most important question for modern humans is how to think of God, once we see that we are free to rethink the conception of God we inherited from those who have gone before us. The arguments about these possibilities are provocative, even exciting. Now that would be a useful debate.
Monday, February 2, 2009
How Can We Heal Religious Divisions?
As we begin 2009, our world is not a peaceful place. There is a tenuous ceasefire in Gaza, which could fall apart at any time. India and Pakistan have heightened alerts on their border, and there is continued violence in Afghanistan. Mercifully, Iraq seems less violent but a suicide bomber killed dozens only a few weeks ago. There are simmering conflicts in Africa, from Darfur in the north to Somalia in the east.
All of these conflicts represent struggles for political power. Yet, there is also a religious element. India is an overwhelmingly Hindu country; Pakistan is overwhelmingly Muslim. Israel is a Jewish country; the residents of Gaza are mostly Muslim. Iraq is torn by a struggle between two groups of Muslims, Sunnis and Shiites. Religious differences exacerbate political differences because they provide a basis for one group to see a rival group as fundamentally inferior. Consider this recent quote from an Egyptian cleric railing at Jews in protesting Israel’s invasion of Gaza: “Muslim brothers, God has inflicted the Muslim nation with a people whom God has become angry at and whom he cursed so he made monkeys and pigs out of them. They killed prophets and messengers and sowed corruption on Earth. They are the most evil on Earth.”
In the last chapter of The Uncertain Believer I imagine a world in which humanity shares a common conception of God. I am not so naïve as to think that will happen soon, certainly not in my lifetime. However, it is not pure fantasy to think that future generations might come to bridge their religious differences. We would continue to have profound differences over many things, but at least one group would not claim that God is on its side.
To begin to close the religious fault lines that divide us, we have to see history in a different way. In particular, we need to stop thinking of our ancestors as having arrived at the truth about the nature of the world. Doing so traps us into replaying ancient conflicts that were often based on superstition and irrational biases. Our ancestors tried to understand the world as well as they could based on the knowledge they had, and there is much wisdom we can draw from ancient sources, including the Bible, the Qur'an, classic Greek plays, and so on. But looking to ancient texts to explain the fundamental nature of the universe is equivalent to relying on scientific textbooks that are a thousand years out of date. Even Isaac Newton, perhaps the greatest scientist in history, had only a limited ability to understand the nature of matter. He knew nothing of subatomic particles or black holes. He could not conceive of how the universe could be the way it is without a divine, all-powerful creator who set the universe in motion.
It is possible to start now to overcome the religious conflicts that divide us. One of the essential requirements is to think for ourselves about the nature of God and the universe, rather than to accept without question the beliefs of our ancient ancestors. I have no illusions that the world will stop fighting wars that are at least partly religious any time soon. But there is value is thinking about what such a day might be like.
All of these conflicts represent struggles for political power. Yet, there is also a religious element. India is an overwhelmingly Hindu country; Pakistan is overwhelmingly Muslim. Israel is a Jewish country; the residents of Gaza are mostly Muslim. Iraq is torn by a struggle between two groups of Muslims, Sunnis and Shiites. Religious differences exacerbate political differences because they provide a basis for one group to see a rival group as fundamentally inferior. Consider this recent quote from an Egyptian cleric railing at Jews in protesting Israel’s invasion of Gaza: “Muslim brothers, God has inflicted the Muslim nation with a people whom God has become angry at and whom he cursed so he made monkeys and pigs out of them. They killed prophets and messengers and sowed corruption on Earth. They are the most evil on Earth.”
In the last chapter of The Uncertain Believer I imagine a world in which humanity shares a common conception of God. I am not so naïve as to think that will happen soon, certainly not in my lifetime. However, it is not pure fantasy to think that future generations might come to bridge their religious differences. We would continue to have profound differences over many things, but at least one group would not claim that God is on its side.
To begin to close the religious fault lines that divide us, we have to see history in a different way. In particular, we need to stop thinking of our ancestors as having arrived at the truth about the nature of the world. Doing so traps us into replaying ancient conflicts that were often based on superstition and irrational biases. Our ancestors tried to understand the world as well as they could based on the knowledge they had, and there is much wisdom we can draw from ancient sources, including the Bible, the Qur'an, classic Greek plays, and so on. But looking to ancient texts to explain the fundamental nature of the universe is equivalent to relying on scientific textbooks that are a thousand years out of date. Even Isaac Newton, perhaps the greatest scientist in history, had only a limited ability to understand the nature of matter. He knew nothing of subatomic particles or black holes. He could not conceive of how the universe could be the way it is without a divine, all-powerful creator who set the universe in motion.
It is possible to start now to overcome the religious conflicts that divide us. One of the essential requirements is to think for ourselves about the nature of God and the universe, rather than to accept without question the beliefs of our ancient ancestors. I have no illusions that the world will stop fighting wars that are at least partly religious any time soon. But there is value is thinking about what such a day might be like.
Monday, January 26, 2009
Conceptions of God in the Obama Inauguration
Inauguration speeches almost always invoke the idea of God one way or another. They tell us how Presidents, and perhaps how much of the country, understands God and what they think God has to do with our lives. God was prominently featured at President Obama’s inauguration, both by him and by the two ministers who delivered prayers, Pastor Rick Warren and Reverend Joseph Lowery. All of them spoke of God as a powerful, omniscient being who can intervene in the world. Warren’s prayer was probably the most explicit in creating this image. His prayer began: “Almighty God, our Father, everything we see and everything we can’t see exists because of you alone. It also comes from you. It all belongs to you. It all exists for your glory.” Those phrases create a clear picture of a Divine Being who presides over the universe. Moreover, the purpose of our existence is to worship this Being. That is clearly suggested by the idea that the entire universe “exists for your glory.”
In The Uncertain Believer I argue that we need to rethink our conception of God in order to reconcile God with what scientists tell us about the nature of the universe. It means that we should move beyond the confines of religious traditions that were formed by our pre-scientific ancestors two thousand years ago. In my view, that means that we should begin to think of God differently from the Divine Being described by President Obama, Reverend Lowery and Pastor Warren. And even if we find it difficult to abandon the idea that God is a Being, we should think of God in a more inclusive way, one that does not insist on specific beliefs about how God has intervened in the world.
How inclusive were the three speakers when they referred to God? How much did each one advocate a particular view of God’s intervention in the world? The comparison is striking. President Obama said: “We are a nation of Christians and Muslims, Jews and Hindus – and non-believers.” We are a nation with “God’s grace upon us,” – that is, God’s grace is on all of us, not those with particular beliefs. Reverend Lowery encouraged us to take the power of fellowship and family “back to our homes, our workplace, our churches, our temples, our mosques, or wherever we seek your will.” Again, the image is that God is a part of the lives of all of us. But, consider how Pastor Warren ended his prayer: “I humbly ask this in the name of the one who changed my life, Yeshua, Isa, Jesus [with a Spanish pronunciation], Jesus…” A prayer to God does not become inclusive just because it refers to Jesus in different languages. Sadly, Warren’s prayer excluded many of us. In the coming weeks, I will suggest ways that we can think of God in a much more inclusive way.
In The Uncertain Believer I argue that we need to rethink our conception of God in order to reconcile God with what scientists tell us about the nature of the universe. It means that we should move beyond the confines of religious traditions that were formed by our pre-scientific ancestors two thousand years ago. In my view, that means that we should begin to think of God differently from the Divine Being described by President Obama, Reverend Lowery and Pastor Warren. And even if we find it difficult to abandon the idea that God is a Being, we should think of God in a more inclusive way, one that does not insist on specific beliefs about how God has intervened in the world.
How inclusive were the three speakers when they referred to God? How much did each one advocate a particular view of God’s intervention in the world? The comparison is striking. President Obama said: “We are a nation of Christians and Muslims, Jews and Hindus – and non-believers.” We are a nation with “God’s grace upon us,” – that is, God’s grace is on all of us, not those with particular beliefs. Reverend Lowery encouraged us to take the power of fellowship and family “back to our homes, our workplace, our churches, our temples, our mosques, or wherever we seek your will.” Again, the image is that God is a part of the lives of all of us. But, consider how Pastor Warren ended his prayer: “I humbly ask this in the name of the one who changed my life, Yeshua, Isa, Jesus [with a Spanish pronunciation], Jesus…” A prayer to God does not become inclusive just because it refers to Jesus in different languages. Sadly, Warren’s prayer excluded many of us. In the coming weeks, I will suggest ways that we can think of God in a much more inclusive way.
Labels:
American,
Barrack Obama,
Catholics,
Christians,
Culture,
Faith,
Jews,
Mohammed,
Muslim,
President,
Protestants,
Quran
Monday, January 19, 2009
America's One God Tradition
Barrack Obama has announced that he will be sworn in to office as the 44th President using the same Bible that Abraham Lincoln used at his first inauguration. No doubt there will be considerable press commentary about the use of this famous Christian Bible. At the same time, we will be reminded of the rumors during the campaign that Obama is a Muslim and that he was sworn in as a Senator using the Quran. The point of the rumors, of course, was that anyone who is a Muslim should be disqualified from being President. Sadly, I suspect many Americans share this view even if they never believed the rumors about Obama.
We need to rethink our instinctive view that Islam is somehow far outside the mainstream religious tradition of the west. Americans often refer to our “Judeo-Christian tradition.“ This formulation sweeps in the shared religious beliefs of Protestants, Catholics, and Jews, but it excludes many others, including America’s third-largest and fastest-growing religious community – Muslims. It also conveys the historically false notion that the fundamental beliefs of Islam differ radically from those of Jews and Christians. In fact, there is a powerful commonality that unites Jews, Christians, and Muslims.
The core of that tradition is belief in one God. That core belief, first adopted by Jews in the face of ancient polytheism, carried on by Christians in a world dominated by Roman culture, and proclaimed by Mohammed in a polytheistic Arab society, unites these three great religious faiths and sets them apart from other religious beliefs. All three faiths look to Abraham as their great patriarch. All three pray to the God to whom Abraham prayed, whether they call God Jahwheh, Allah, or simply God.
In The Uncertain Believer, I discuss the long tradition of each army in a war claiming that God is on its side. I argue that we need to rethink our conception of God in many ways, including abandoning this ancient idea that God takes sides. In his second Inaugural Address in March 1865, Abraham Lincoln made of a point of saying that God was not on either side of the Civil War that had torn the nation apart. Almost a century and a half later, we should at least be able to acknowledge that both Americans and Muslims pray to the same God, although some corrupt the values for which this God stands.
One of the most constructive steps we can take to promote better relations with the Arab world is to begin to speak of this Judeo-Christian-Islamic tradition. If that is too poly-syllabic, perhaps the “Abrahamic” or simply “one God” tradition is easier to convey. The point is to recognize the common fundamental beliefs of these three faiths. In addition to a belief in one powerful and just God, all three faiths emphasize the obligation to take care of the disadvantaged and to live a just and loving life.
It is true that there are fundamental differences among these faiths about the nature and significance of Jesus, but that difference has not undercut the shared tradition of Jews and Christians in the religious life of America. There are also significant differences about the role of women, the relationship of religion and the state, and the possibility of accommodation with other religious faiths. Yet, the differences among mainstream Christianity, Judaism and Islam on these issues are probably less significant than the divisions within each faith.
Some interpretations of the Quran mandate second-class citizenship for women but others do not. (Compare the number of women Muslims who have been heads of state with the number of women who have been U.S. Presidents.) Some radical interpretations of the Quran seem to endorse terrorism, but mainstream interpretations mandate tolerance and condemn aggression. We do not speak of Catholic or Protestant terrorists when referring to violence in Northern Ireland, even if terrorists claim to act in the name of their faith. In fact, they have abandoned the principles of their faith. In the same way, we should stop confusing radicals who act in the name of Islam with Islam itself. A single speech by the President about the values that unite Jews, Christians and Muslims would do more to repair the breach with the Arab world than all the millions we have spent in the futile public relations campaign to prop up America’s image in the Middle East.
We need to rethink our instinctive view that Islam is somehow far outside the mainstream religious tradition of the west. Americans often refer to our “Judeo-Christian tradition.“ This formulation sweeps in the shared religious beliefs of Protestants, Catholics, and Jews, but it excludes many others, including America’s third-largest and fastest-growing religious community – Muslims. It also conveys the historically false notion that the fundamental beliefs of Islam differ radically from those of Jews and Christians. In fact, there is a powerful commonality that unites Jews, Christians, and Muslims.
The core of that tradition is belief in one God. That core belief, first adopted by Jews in the face of ancient polytheism, carried on by Christians in a world dominated by Roman culture, and proclaimed by Mohammed in a polytheistic Arab society, unites these three great religious faiths and sets them apart from other religious beliefs. All three faiths look to Abraham as their great patriarch. All three pray to the God to whom Abraham prayed, whether they call God Jahwheh, Allah, or simply God.
In The Uncertain Believer, I discuss the long tradition of each army in a war claiming that God is on its side. I argue that we need to rethink our conception of God in many ways, including abandoning this ancient idea that God takes sides. In his second Inaugural Address in March 1865, Abraham Lincoln made of a point of saying that God was not on either side of the Civil War that had torn the nation apart. Almost a century and a half later, we should at least be able to acknowledge that both Americans and Muslims pray to the same God, although some corrupt the values for which this God stands.
One of the most constructive steps we can take to promote better relations with the Arab world is to begin to speak of this Judeo-Christian-Islamic tradition. If that is too poly-syllabic, perhaps the “Abrahamic” or simply “one God” tradition is easier to convey. The point is to recognize the common fundamental beliefs of these three faiths. In addition to a belief in one powerful and just God, all three faiths emphasize the obligation to take care of the disadvantaged and to live a just and loving life.
It is true that there are fundamental differences among these faiths about the nature and significance of Jesus, but that difference has not undercut the shared tradition of Jews and Christians in the religious life of America. There are also significant differences about the role of women, the relationship of religion and the state, and the possibility of accommodation with other religious faiths. Yet, the differences among mainstream Christianity, Judaism and Islam on these issues are probably less significant than the divisions within each faith.
Some interpretations of the Quran mandate second-class citizenship for women but others do not. (Compare the number of women Muslims who have been heads of state with the number of women who have been U.S. Presidents.) Some radical interpretations of the Quran seem to endorse terrorism, but mainstream interpretations mandate tolerance and condemn aggression. We do not speak of Catholic or Protestant terrorists when referring to violence in Northern Ireland, even if terrorists claim to act in the name of their faith. In fact, they have abandoned the principles of their faith. In the same way, we should stop confusing radicals who act in the name of Islam with Islam itself. A single speech by the President about the values that unite Jews, Christians and Muslims would do more to repair the breach with the Arab world than all the millions we have spent in the futile public relations campaign to prop up America’s image in the Middle East.
Labels:
American,
Barrack Obama,
Catholics,
Christians,
Culture,
Faith,
Jews,
Mohammed,
Muslim,
President,
Protestants,
Quran
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)

